Dr Dray has reviewed 61 sunscreens and approved most of them. Her Guru Score for this category is 70%, and she named 8 outright winners. What sets those winners apart, in her view, almost always comes down to how a formula feels on skin.
What does Dr Dray recommend in sunscreen?
She keeps coming back to sunscreens that hydrate without being greasy, don't sting around the eyes, and feel light enough to actually reapply during the day. When a formula uses iron oxides for its tint, she tends to flag that as a bonus. Those pigments may help protect against visible light, which matters most for people with medium to deep skin tones who are managing hyperpigmentation. For oily skin, she consistently points to matte but moisturizing options like EltaMD UV Clear Broad-Spectrum SPF 46, praising it for giving hydration with no shine.
In their words
"One of my all-time favorite sunscreens for both face and body is this one from Bondi Sands. I recommend it all the time because it's fragrance-free. It's pretty affordable. It's deeply hydrating. It doesn't burn or sting around the eyes. It's comfortable to wear. It's comfortable to reapply. And it's also moisturizing without being greasy or heavy. It claims to offer 72 hours of hydration. And I believe that it is a really nice moisturizer. I personally like using this a lot on my legs throughout the summer months because [...] it's kind of like putting on a body moisturizer in the morning. I'm somebody who has a tendency towards dry skin anyway, so it's kind of like a two for one."
"It has niacinamide, which is great for the moisture barrier. The tint blends into the skin very well. When I am wearing this sunscreen and using it on a daily basis as my everyday moisturizer with sunscreen for day to day use, I see a noticeable difference in just the smoothness and luminosity of my skin while wearing this, so it really is cosmetically a very nice formula. Everything DRMTLGY I've ever tried has been a win, and I even had the opportunity to visit their factory where they make this and go on a tour. [...] This is one I buy over and over and over again. This most recent bottle and the past few bottles I've actually purchased on Amazon, so if you're an Amazon shopper you can get it there. It's a hybrid sunscreen, so it has zinc and octinoxate in it. It also has a tint, and the tint comes from iron oxides, which may help in offering protection from visible light that could otherwise worsen hyperpigmentation, especially for people who have medium to deep skin tones."
"Bioré has sunscreens in Japan which are very good and do contain the newly approved sunscreen ingredient. I have used many of those Bioré sunscreens in the past, including the Bioré UV Aqua Rich Watery Essence. [...] They were some of the first Japanese sunscreens I ever tried, and I really really like them. They do have a [...] light lemon citrus fragrance, not strong or headache-inducing, but if you're allergic to fragrance you would want to avoid them. [...] They're a lightweight, watery gel that's a lot more comfortable to use."
"This one's really good and it's still $9.99, which is great. It's water resistant and works really well on the face and the body. This is an underrated sunscreen."
"Their zero cast sunscreen. Don't sleep on that. Don't sleep on that. That is an amazing no white cast. That is that's one of my all-time favorites from Anua."
"I have always recommended UV Clear and UV Daily because they look really nice on the skin and in my opinion these are the quintessential matte formulas. There is no shine with these sunscreens. They're a lightweight lotion formula though so they're moisturizing. They don't have alcohol denaturant like many gel sunscreens that I recommend for oily skin types but in contrast to a lot of lotion cream formulas they're not shiny. [...] UV Daily on the other hand does not have niacinamide so that might help you out if you're sensitive to that ingredient."
How many sunscreens has Dr Dray reviewed?
Dr Dray has reviewed 61 sunscreens, for a Guru Score of 70%. 43 approved, 12 mixed, and 6 skipped.
What has Dr Dray skipped in sunscreen?
Nearly every sunscreen Dr Dray skipped failed on feel. An oily or heavy finish was the most common reason. She was particularly surprised by The Ordinary UV Filters SPF 45 Serum, which she described as leaving her looking like a glazed donut, despite being a lightweight liquid. She also skipped Vacation Sunscreen after it stung her eyes and felt greasy, and said she could not understand the appeal of a sunscreen oil.
"I don't know how it is that The Ordinary managed to mess it up because they took a chemical sunscreen and somehow made it just as uncomfortable to wear as the mineral counterparts, this UV Filters SPF 45 serum, because this thing is so oily. Many mineral sunscreens feel more comfortable than this. It's so oily. It's like, did I just put cleansing balm all over my face? When you put it on, there's no white cast. [...] Great. We expect that with a chemical sunscreen. But it feels heavy. It comes out a thin liquid fluid, but it feels heavy. Like it feels like I have a thin film of baby oil all over my face. And you look shiny. You look [...] like a glazed donut."
"I tried the Vacation Sunscreen that is made to look like baby oil packaging and that burned my eyes for sure. And I felt like I was getting ready to hop in a deep fryer and be somebody's Friday night dinner. I felt like I was about to turn into a fish stick. Yeah. No thanks. It baffles me because one of the chief complaints people have with sunscreens, especially the American ones, is, 'Oh, they feel too greasy. They feel too oily. They make me look shiny.' So, you're going to lube up with a thick layer of sunscreen oil? I don't understand the appeal of these."
"Years ago I tried the Supergoop Glow Screen. It's an organic sunscreen, no white cast, it's tinted, not water resistant, and it didn't burn around my eyes. The finish was okay, a little shiny, and the tint is very shimmery, so it gives you that glittery bronze look, which is okay, you may really like that. Personally, for me it just was not my favorite."
"I tried this out and it is super smooth. The fragrance in this isn't too strong and it doesn't linger, but man it leaves your skin feeling really oily for a long time."
What should you take from Dr Dray's picks?
Dr Dray is generous with her sunscreen approvals, and that generosity has a shape. A formula has to feel comfortable on skin, sit light through the day, and not sting around the eyes. She named 8 outright winners across her 61 reviews. Almost every sunscreen she skipped failed for the exact same reason. It felt wrong on skin.
Watch Dr Dray say it
Every verdict here comes from a video. These are the moments themselves, each one jumping straight to the bit about that product.
- Supergoop Unseen Sunscreen SPF 40Named a winnerWatch at 8:23
- DRMTLGY Universal Tinted Moisturizer SPF 46Named a winnerWatch at 5:25
- Black Girl Sunscreen SPF 30Named a winnerWatch at 6:37
- Bondi Sands SPF 50 SunscreenNamed a winnerWatch at 2:39
- Anua ZeroCast Moisturizing Finish SunscreenNamed a winnerWatch at 15:34
- Cetaphil Sheer Mineral Face Liquid Sunscreen SPF 50Named a winnerWatch at 1:41
- Blue Lizard Mineral Sunscreen SPF 50Named a winnerWatch at 5:16
- Skin Aqua UV Super Moisture MilkNamed a winnerWatch at 12:03
- The Ordinary UV Filters SPF 45 SerumSkipped itWatch at 4:57
- Vacation SunscreenSkipped itWatch at 9:23
- Supergoop Glow Screen SunscreenSkipped itWatch at 0:49
- Sun Bum SPF 70Skipped itWatch at 1:34
- Sun Bum Face Mist SPF 45Skipped itWatch at 10:46
- Naked Sundays Mineral SunscreenSkipped itWatch at 5:46
- DRMTLGY Tinted SunscreenRated itWatch at 7:46
- Biore UV Aqua Rich Watery Essence SPF 50+ PA++++Rated itWatch at 12:29
- EltaMD UV DailyRated itWatch at 1:48
- Haruharu Wonder Black Rice Pure Mineral Relief Daily SunscreenRated itWatch at 11:23
- Klairs All Day Airy SunscreenRated itWatch at 0:00
- BYOMA Ultra Light Face Fluid SPF 50Rated itWatch at 8:28
- Neutrogena Ultra Sheer Dry-Touch SPF 70Rated itWatch at 13:58
- BYOMA SPF 30 Ultra Light Face FluidRated itWatch at 6:26
- Cocokind SunscreenRated itWatch at 3:15
- Eucerin Sensitive Mineral Face Sunscreen SPF 35Rated itWatch at 10:39
About this expert
See everything Dr Dray has reviewed
Related guides
This guide reflects what Dr Dray said across their videos about 61 products in sunscreen, aggregated by The Guru Index. Sponsored takes are excluded. The Guru Score is our read on how warmly they talk about them. It is general information, not medical advice.