Sincerely Miss Ash has reviewed more than 20 eye care products, and her record leans positive. She approved most of what she tested, with only a few skips. Her approval rate sits at 74%, which means she has a real bar to clear but will back a product that earns it.
What does Sincerely Miss Ash recommend in eye care?
The thing she keeps coming back to is multi-tasking. She goes for products that handle several concerns at once: depuffing, firming, brightening, and tackling fine lines, rather than doing just one job. She named the NIOD Fractionated Eye Contour Concentrate her outright winner. She has used it for years and says it does it all, with exosomes and growth factors she finds genuinely effective. She also has a long history with the Dr. Dennis Gross Advanced Retinol Plus Ferulic Triple Correction Eye Serum, saying it has prevented milia for her across seven years of steady use. For those who want results without strong actives like retinol or vitamin C, she pointed to the Biossance Squalane + Marine Algae Eye Cream as a gentler pick that still firms and addresses fine lines. She called the La Roche-Posay Toleriane Dermallergo Eye Cream super gentle and very moisturising, giving it a nod for sensitive skin.
In her words
"This went viral on TikTok [...] and after seeing it she bought it and has been hooked ever since. It can be used morning and evening; she mainly uses it [...] in the morning because she wakes up puffy under her eyes and sometimes under the brow bone, and applying it [...] there helps depuff."
"I've been using it for years. I would buy this first before that eye serum because this does it all and I really like the cream. It's a little bit more moisturizing on the skin and this has the exosomes, the growth factors, the NIOD one does not. So, this just does a little bit more in my opinion and from my experience."
"This is something that you can use to get rid of red eye, not pink eye due to conjunctivitis because I don't think this would work for that. But this does a really good job to get rid of the redness and then the whites of your eyes are white and bright and you just look more awake. I just use it when I need it and it does a really good job for when you need something in a pinch to get rid of that red eye."
"If you wish to use an eye cream then the one from La Roche Posay is really lovely as well it's super gentle very moisturizing and it's also a great product to incorporate around the eyes"
"It got rid of my milia within 3 months or so, and this has prevented milia as well. [...] This is a product that I have been using consistently for the last 7 years and it never ever disappoints. It will target all eye concerns as well. This is more of a gel, though they do consider it a serum, but [...] it's a little bit thicker. It has bakuchiol, which is a plant-based alternative to retinol that works very similar to what retinol does, but it's more gentle."
"This has been a favorite of mine for quite some time and I really love this one a lot. [...] The reason why I like this a lot is because this helps to brighten it moisturizes it lifts firms and addresses fine lines and wrinkles without using retinol bioactive peptides vitamin C all of those other types of active ingredients. So if you're looking for an eye cream that tackles fine lines and wrinkles without those ingredients then this would be a great option to look into."
How many eye care products has Sincerely Miss Ash reviewed?
Sincerely Miss Ash has reviewed 23 eye care products, for an approval rate of 74%. 17 approved, 1 mixed, and 5 skipped.
What has Sincerely Miss Ash skipped in eye care?
The skips she gave were mostly about formulation or redundancy, not serious problems. She found The Ordinary Caffeine Solution 5% + EGCG drying and said it did not depuff for her, which is the one thing it is meant to do. With the Paula's Choice C15 Super Boost Eye Cream, she felt it was brightening and moisturising but that other products she had tried did more for signs of ageing, so it did not stand out enough to keep. A few others, like the L'Oreal Revitalift Caffeine Plus HA Eye Serum, she called a reasonable option she was not rushing to repurchase because she already had serums she liked better in rotation.
"They've always had their caffeine solution and that one is designed for de-puffing. I found that that formulation was very drying and I also didn't feel like it depuffed whatsoever."
"Now, I'm not going to be purchasing this at the moment just because my go-to is eye serums and I have a lot of eye serums that I need to use up first, and sometimes I will put a regular eye cream on top of those eye serums just to keep the skin nice and moisturized, but also sometimes I just use my face moisturizers and bring them up around the eyes, so I don't need to pick up another one at this time. But this would be one that I would refer back to down the road for sure."
"If you have dullness underneath your eyes, then this could possibly be a product that would work for you. Yes, it was a little bit brightening and yes, it is very moisturizing, but there are other eye serums and eye creams that I have used in the past that have performed better than this. The other eye serums and eye creams that I have talked about contain more ingredients to target signs of aging, like the Neostrata Fractionated Eye Contour Concentrate."
"It's a great drugstore option and it's really nice underneath your sunscreen and makeup. But at this time I am not going to repurchase only because I have other eye serums that I am currently using that I am loving a little bit more, but this would be another option to resort to down the road if I felt like I needed it."
What should you take from Sincerely Miss Ash's picks?
If you want to know what Sincerely Miss Ash actually reaches for herself, it is the NIOD Fractionated Eye Contour Concentrate, the one she named her top pick and uses consistently. Her broader record shows she values products that do more than one job and that work for sensitive skin around the eye area. A drying formula or a single-benefit product is likely to earn a skip from her, so her approvals make a useful shortlist for anyone who wants a hardworking eye product without the irritation.
Watch Sincerely Miss Ash say it
Every verdict here comes from a video. These are the moments themselves, each one jumping straight to the bit about that product.
- NIOD Fractionated Eye Contour ConcentrateNamed a winnerWatch at 13:26
- The Ordinary Caffeine Solution 5% + EGCGSkipped itWatch at 7:30
- The INKEY List Retinol Eye CreamSkipped itWatch at 19:15
- Paula's Choice C15 Super Boost Eye CreamSkipped itWatch at 17:01
- L'Oreal Revitalift Caffeine Plus HA Eye SerumSkipped itWatch at 18:34
- First Aid Beauty Brighten and Glow Eye Cream with NiacinamideSkipped itWatch at 8:21
- RoC Multi Correxion Revive + Glow Eye BalmRated itWatch at 12:31
- Lumify Redness Reliever Eye DropsRated itWatch at 9:17
- La Roche-Posay Toleriane Dermallergo Eye CreamRated itWatch at 8:34
- Dr. Dennis Gross Advanced Retinol Plus Ferulic Triple Correction Eye SerumRated itWatch at 4:54
- Biossance Squalane + Marine Algae Eye CreamRated itWatch at 13:43
- CeraVe Skin Renewing Vitamin C Eye CreamRated itWatch at 11:45
- ILIA Bright Start Activated Eye CreamRated itWatch at 11:06
- Drunk Elephant A-Shaba Complex Eye SerumRated itWatch at 5:11
- Revision Skincare D.E.J. Eye CreamRated itWatch at 15:05
- Cocokind Peptide Fine Line Eye GelRated itWatch at 11:39
- Summer Fridays Light Aura Vitamin C Plus Peptide Eye CreamRated itWatch at 9:14
- Murad Retinol Resculpt Eye TreatmentRated itWatch at 3:49
- Avène Physiolift Eye CreamRated itWatch at 6:22
- Biossance Squalane + Peptide Eye GelRated itWatch at 7:04
- The Ordinary Lacto-PDRN 4% + B9 Eye CreamRated itWatch at 11:39
- iNNBEAUTY PROJECT Bright & Tight Dark Circle Firming Eye CreamRated itWatch at 6:27
About this expert
See everything Sincerely Miss Ash has reviewed
Expert rankings
Related guides
This guide reflects what Sincerely Miss Ash said across her videos about 23 products in eye care, aggregated by The Guru Index. Sponsored takes are excluded. The approval rate is the share of these products she approved. It is general information, not medical advice.