James Welsh has tested a lot of sunscreens. He has rosacea, so he watches closely how a formula sits on skin, whether it triggers redness, and how it looks on the face. His approval rate of 60% tells you he is picky, and his skips are just as useful as his approvals.
What does James Welsh recommend in sunscreen?
James tends to approve sunscreens that feel like skincare rather than sunscreen. He loves a lightweight, non-sticky finish and keeps coming back to formulas that both hydrate and soothe. The Tirtir Hydro UV Shield Sunscreen SPF 50+ impressed him with its hyaluronic acid, collagen and panthenol. He said it felt like a lightweight moisturiser, layered well under makeup, and left no stickiness. He named Undefined Beauty RNR Sun Serum SPF 50 his single category winner, calling it probably his favourite sunscreen of all time after two years of steady use. He also praised Prequel Sun Barrier Mineral Sunscreen Broad Spectrum SPF 50 for people with rosacea, noting that centella asiatica in the formula helps calm redness. Because it is a mineral sunscreen, he flagged it will not suit deeper skin tones. Most mineral filters still give him a grey cast, so finding one with a peachy tint that worked for him was a big deal.
In his words
"TirTir's Hydro UV Shield Sunscreen is so good I immediately had to buy another one. It's broad spectrum, full protection and chemical so there's no white cast, and it just feels like a lightweight moisturizer. It has three different weights of hyaluronic acid for nice hydration, plus collagen, aloe vera and panthenol, so you're hydrated, moisturized and soothed with no stickiness or greasiness, and it layers perfectly under makeup. It does have a slight fragrance, which has never been an issue for me. If you want glowy, dewy, well-hydrated, plumped-up skin without irritation or that sunscreen feeling, this one's perfect. I've been reaching for it nonstop over the vast majority of my sunscreen collection."
"Probably my favorite sunscreen of all time, this is a fully mineral tinted sunscreen available in three shades, it's got cica mushroom in it which is very hydrating, and niacinamide, it gives you a very natural looking glow, sometimes people ask if I'm wearing makeup but it's not heavy coverage. I've been using this solidly for about 2 years now, absolutely love it, never going to stop using it."
"One of their best and I would say most iconic products is their unseen sunscreen, purely because everyone can use it, it works great as a sunscreen, a lot of clear sunscreens can be very greasy and oily looking, this one isn't, in my opinion, and it doesn't sting my eyes."
"The Sun Barrier Mineral Sunscreen Broad Spectrum SPF 50 plus PA4 plus is from Prequel and is one of my favorite mineral sunscreens as somebody with rosacea, because chemical sunscreens can flare me up sometimes. This is a mineral sunscreen so those with deeper skin tones will not be able to use this. It does have a slight peachy tint to it which I don't think they did to try and counterbalance that at all, but this peachy hue kind of blends into the skin and leaves this more natural, more even kind of finish to the skin. I am slightly tanned and I do struggle with most mineral sunscreen still to be honest with you; it gives me like this gray finish to my skin. So to have this peachy hue that really glows and shines through those mineral filters is perfect for me. It contains bisoprolol and centella asiatica which helps reduce redness as well, which I find sunscreens always give me, and it's not glass skin, but it has ingredients which reduce skin stress and help with UV exposure, and they have a skin care technology called Lamellar phase emotion which is structurally similar to intercellular skin lipids."
"The ginseng moist sun serum is another amazing sunscreen I've not seen enough people talk about. If you are super oily and you hate layering sunscreen throughout the day and reapplying every two hours because you just feel like other sunscreens get greasy, it sits on your skin, makes you look oily, then you should try this. This is super lightweight. There's an SPF 50+ PA++++ with 30% ginseng root extract which is great antioxidant to help fight free radical damage along with the sun protection, and the arbutin will kind of help even everything out."
"And super goop play. This is a mineral sunscreen"
How many sunscreens has James Welsh reviewed?
James Welsh has reviewed 40 sunscreens, for an approval rate of 60%. 24 approved, 3 mixed, and 13 skipped.
What has James Welsh skipped in sunscreen?
He skipped Ultra Violette Lean Screen Mattifying SPF 50 Zinc Sunscreen after independent lab tests returned an SPF of just four or five, nowhere near the SPF 50+ on the label. He felt the price made that gap worse. He skipped Sol de Janeiro Rio Radiance SPF 50 Body Lotion entirely on smell, calling it horrific. He skipped Supergoop Glow Screen Sunscreen SPF 40 because the pearlescent finish clung to every pore and made his skin look dirty and sweaty. And he gave CeraVe AM Facial Moisturizing Lotion SPF 30 a hard look on value, pointing out that prices have nearly doubled in some cases since the brand was bought by a large conglomerate. That undercuts its reputation as affordable drugstore skincare.
"I hate the smell of this sunscreen. Horrific. It was horrible. And I was doing a meet and greet and the queue was going past the display and I saw people in the queue who were coming to meet me and Robert picking up the product and smelling it and pulling a face. A lot of people didn't like the smell."
"Despite being marketed as having an SPF rating of 50 plus, Choice revealed that their test returned an SPF rating of just four. This rating was so low that Choice actually sent a sample to another lab in Germany just to double-check the results, and that came back with an SPF rating for Lean Screen of five. So slightly better, I guess, but not the rating they promised. A drop from a rating of 50 plus to just four or five would be bad enough for any sunscreen product. But considering that Ultraviolet's products aren't cheap, it was even more disappointing to consumers."
"I didn't want to waste money on this and I didn't—it was in a Sephora gift bag. I've said before I don't really get along with tinted sunscreens. In real life it's showing up every single bit of texture on my skin. It looks like I've got liquid bronzer on all over my face. The pearlescent finish is clinging to every pore and makes me look dirty and sweaty. It doesn't sting and feels fine, but I don't like it at all. I want to take it off immediately."
"One thing I noticed as well, it's also not as affordable and easily accessible as it used to be. Over the past few years, CeraVe has implemented quite a few price increases across their whole range. In March of 2023, a Target employee actually highlighted a huge price hike, mentioning that certain items have nearly doubled in price. For example, a 3 ounce face moisturizer with SPF 30 increased from $14.99 to $24.49. They're also now owned by a huge conglomerate who can in all reality afford to keep these prices down. So I feel like a lot of people have this idea that they're still basic, affordable skincare at a drugstore price level, when really they kind of aren't."
What should you take from James Welsh's picks?
James Welsh is a genuinely useful guide on sunscreens because he tests them on real skin with rosacea and is honest about formulas that disappoint him. His approval rate of 60% means he skips roughly four in ten, and his reasons are specific and practical. If you want to know which sunscreens actually feel good to wear every day and which ones fall short on finish, SPF accuracy or value, his record is worth reading.
Watch James Welsh say it
Every verdict here comes from a video. These are the moments themselves, each one jumping straight to the bit about that product.
- Undefined Beauty RNR Sun Serum SPF 50Named a winnerWatch at 30:43
- Sol de Janeiro Rio Radiance SPF 50 Body LotionSkipped itWatch at 30:48
- Ultra Violette Lean Screen Mattifying SPF 50 Zinc SunscreenSkipped itWatch at 30:36
- Supergoop Glow Screen Sunscreen SPF 40Skipped itWatch at 16:26
- CeraVe AM Facial Moisturizing Lotion SPF 30Skipped itWatch at 5:15
- The INKEY List Polyglutamic Acid Dewy Sunscreen SPF 30Skipped itWatch at 16:12
- Tower 28 SunnyDays SPF 30 Tinted Sunscreen FoundationSkipped itWatch at 1:52
- Colorescience Sunforgettable Total Protection Brush-On Shield SPF 50Skipped itWatch at 10:35
- Supergoop Resetting 100% Mineral Powder SPF 35Skipped itWatch at 10:30
- Purito Centella Green Level Unscented Sun SPF 50+Skipped itWatch at 6:03
- Garnier Vitamin C Daily UV Brightening Fluid Invisible SPF 50+Skipped itWatch at 20:20
- Keep Cool Soothe Bamboo Sun Essence SPF 50+Skipped itWatch at 6:41
- Bondi Sands SPF 50 Broad Spectrum Sunscreen LotionSkipped itWatch at 37:52
- Bondi Sands Daily Moisturizing Face SPF 50+Skipped itWatch at 11:24
- Tirtir Hydro UV Shield Sunscreen SPF 50+Rated itWatch at 37:05
- Supergoop Unseen Sunscreen SPF 40Rated itWatch at 45:26
- Prequel Sun Barrier Mineral Sunscreen Broad Spectrum SPF 50Rated itWatch at 9:01
- Beauty of Joseon Ginseng Moist Sun Serum SPF 50+ PA++++Rated itWatch at 26:53
- Supergoop Play Everyday Lotion SPF 50Rated itWatch at 3:12
- e.l.f. Suntouchable Whoa Glow SPF 30Rated itWatch at 13:00
- Bloom Effects Tulip Dew Sunscreen Serum SPF 50Rated itWatch at 18:37
- Beauty of Joseon Day Dew Sunscreen Lightweight SPF 50Rated itWatch at 11:02
- Undefined Beauty RNR Mineral SunscreenRated itWatch at 3:11
- Ultra Violette Queen Screen Luminizing Skin Screen SPF 50+Rated itWatch at 9:28
About this expert
See everything James Welsh has reviewed
Related guides
This guide reflects what James Welsh said across his videos about 40 products in sunscreen, aggregated by The Guru Index. Sponsored takes are excluded. The approval rate is the share of these products he approved. It is general information, not medical advice.