Index / Guru guides / Mixed Makeup on oily skin

Mixed Makeup's Guide to Oily Skin: What She Rates and What She Skips

With more than 40 oily-skin products reviewed and an approval rate of 90%, she approves nearly everything she tries and skips almost nothing.

90%Approval rate
37 Yay3 Mixed1 Nay

Mixed Makeup has worked through more than 40 products aimed at oily skin, from cleansers and exfoliants to setting powders and sunscreen. She approved the vast majority of them. Only a few got a mixed take, and she skipped almost nothing outright.

What does Mixed Makeup recommend for oily skin?

She keeps coming back to ingredients that actively manage oil without causing dryness. The Ordinary Niacinamide 10% + Zinc 1% is one she describes as revolutionary for the skincare industry, praising it for balancing, toning, and the way it feels like a layer of protection on the skin. For cleansing, she points to CeraVe Foaming Facial Cleanser as a reliable option that gets the job done with ingredients tolerable for all skin types, sensitive skin included. On exfoliation, she is a fan of salicylic acid in a rinse-off form, rating The INKEY List 2% Salicylic Acid Cleanser as a gentle way to clear clogged pores and balance oil production, and she notes that because it rinses off, it does not keep exfoliating after you wash. She also loves the Dermalogica Daily Microfoliant, a powder that turns into a paste with water and gives a gentle physical scrub.

Mixed Makeup's oily skin picks, in her words

"I'm gonna take the pillow talk lipstick from Charlotte Tilbury because it's so pretty. One of the best lipstick colors ever made."
"This is like holy grail status for me. [...] It's the Dr. Ceuracle Vegan Kombucha Tea Essence. It's a bi-phase formula, meaning it has two different phases in the formula. [...] It has soothing ingredients like chamomile and anise in it. [...] The texture is really nice and soothing. It is a toner for your skin or like an essence, but it also slightly just very slightly moisturizes your skin."
"The Tatcha Rice Polish is one of the best products that Tatcha has out on the market. It is super foamy and creamy. [...] The enzymes that are in the powder are gently exfoliating your skin. You're not going to get as strong of exfoliation as you get with typical AHAs or salicylic acid or anything like that, it's very gentle. Most skin types can tolerate that. The Tatcha Rice Polish is very gentle."
"I love their niacinamide and zinc serum. I think it's just good for all over balancing, toning, and a lot of really good properties, and I also just love the way it feels on my skin. It feels like a layer of protection. [...] The niacinamide serum from the ordinary is a classic. [...] I feel like it was revolutionary for the skincare industry."
"The Foaming Facial Cleanser, this is one that dermatologists recommend because it's just going to clean your skin and [...] get the job done with ingredients that are pretty tolerable for all skin types, especially for people that have sensitive skin."
"I love peel pads like the Dr. Dennis Gross Alpha Beta Peel. I've been using that for a long time, over a decade at this point. I always kind of go back to that. [...] If you want that manual exfoliation, I'm all about a peel pad. I would just try it out like once or twice a week to start and then move into as many times a week as you can."

How many products has Mixed Makeup reviewed for oily skin?

Mixed Makeup has reviewed 41 products for oily skin, for an approval rate of 90%. 37 approved, 3 mixed, and 1 skipped.

What has Mixed Makeup skipped for oily skin?

Her outright skips are rare, and the Medicube Age-R Booster Pro is the one that stands out. She felt her skincare sank in a little better with it, but she could find nothing on the brand's website saying its technology differs from other devices, so to her it read as more marketing. She also wanted to know what it is really doing for your skin: is it actually stimulating collagen, and is it too strong? Her other reservations come through as honest caveats inside her approvals. She found the Milani Make It Last Matte Setting Spray a little too matte for her own skin in a dry climate, and said it made her look a little crusty. Even so, she calls it really good if a matte finish is what you want.

What should you take from Mixed Makeup's picks?

Mixed Makeup's record on oily skin is a confident one. She approves most of what she tries, and her picks tend to share a common thread: ingredients that control oil and clear pores without stripping the skin. The skip that stands out is a device she found short on evidence, and her caveats, like the Milani setting spray being too matte for dry days, are practical ones worth keeping in mind.

Watch Mixed Makeup say it

Every verdict here comes from a video. These are the moments themselves, each one jumping straight to the bit about that product.

About this expert

See everything Mixed Makeup has reviewed

Related guides

This guide reflects what Mixed Makeup said across her videos about 41 products for oily skin, aggregated by The Guru Index. Sponsored takes are excluded. The approval rate is the share of these products she approved. It is general information, not medical advice.