Lip products are a category where Doctorly gets specific fast. The two dermatologists behind the channel have looked at more than 10 of them, from basic drugstore staples to pricier masks and treatments, and they approved just under half. That split says something on its own: they are not easily won over here.
What does Doctorly recommend in lip?
The ones they approved tend to share a few things. Simple, non-irritating formulas come up again and again. They praised Vaseline Lip Therapy Original for its straightforward petrolatum base and its price, and said they'd still recommend it even though they have their own lip product. They approved Glossier Balm Dotcom for being thick and gentle, calling it one of those options that 'really just saved my skin.' The INKEY List Tripeptide Plumping Lip Balm got their nod too. They said they strongly prefer peptide-based plumpers over menthol or camphor formulas, which they called 'trashier and worse.' SPF options made the cut when the sunscreen ingredients were sound. Paula's Choice Lip SPF was described as something they liked quite a bit and found affordable. Avène Lip Balm SPF was singled out as their product of the day.
In their words
"The Inkey List has that controversial plumping lip balm that sits with those peptides, but I much prefer it to anything else, like menthol or camphor formulas, which are trashier and worse."
"I love Vaseline for the lips. I truly always continue to recommend this even though I have my own lip product which has petrolatum in it. I still recommend this because of the price point on it. Overall love this except I would take the dye out and just use their regular pure petrolatum for Vaseline."
"The Avène lip balm is the product of the day. Someone recommended it to me."
"This is very, very gentle, hydrating, and might help with its intended goal. So I actually like it a lot for what it is. It tastes pretty weird, so if you can tolerate that, that's up to you. It is flavor-free and fragrance-free, so that's to be anticipated, but it does have a little bit of a weird taste."
"The Glossier Balm Dotcom, it's a balm, it's thick like wall paste. [...] Those are extremely gentle options that really just saved my skin."
"Paula's Choice also has one that's pretty affordable. I think it's like 10 bucks. It's a Lip SPF that I've tried that I also liked quite a bit too."
How many lip products has Doctorly reviewed?
Doctorly has reviewed 15 lip products, for an approval rate of 47%. 7 approved, 3 mixed, and 5 skipped.
What has Doctorly skipped in lip?
Their skips are where the real detail is. Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick Plus Sunscreen was one they said people should not buy. They pointed to oxybenzone as an ingredient with a good reason to avoid it, linking it to lip irritation, peeling, and itchiness. Carmex Classic Lip Balm got a harder pass. They explained how the numbing sensation gives short-term relief while allergens, flavors, and fragrances quietly cause low-level inflammation underneath, and compared that cycle to painkiller dependence. Sun Bum Sunscreen Lip Balm SPF 30 was skipped because its banana scent and taste made people lick their lips, which they said creates a problem rather than solving one. Tree Hut Sugar Lips Lip Butter was rich and glossy but, they said, a bad product once you look past the texture.
"To me, that's a compelling reason not to use oxybenzone. If you [...] had to suspect why these people are suddenly getting their lips exploding and then getting peeling and itchiness on the lips, it's because of the oxybenzone and not because of the underlying base of Aquaphor. [...] I'm at a point where I'm going to tell people not to purchase this product. Don't buy this lip SPF from Aquaphor. This is not the best product you should be using to protect your lips in the sun."
"If you're in a situation where you went skiing or you got a sunburn, that Carmex numbing sensation is going to give you some relief for some time, but in the background you're going to be dealing with a low level of inflammation from the common allergens, flavors, fragrances in this product. This will give you temporary relief, which is addicting to get temporary relief just like painkillers can become addicting. I would avoid this product. I would never use this again."
"It does smell nice, wow, look how oily it is. I don't like this at all. It tastes like banana, it tastes good, that's a problem. That's a big problem, just like with the sugar lip scrubs it has you licking your lips, it's creating a big problem. I don't like it at all. It's a no for me."
"It's very rich, kind of a hug when you have that kind of microcrystalline wax. [...] It's grippy. I mean, it's obviously a bad product for your lips though. It has that glossy look, [...] that glowy look to it, [...] but all the other ingredients make it a no for me."
What should you take from Doctorly's picks?
Doctorly's record on lip products comes down to a clear preference: simple bases, no irritating fragrance or flavor, and SPF only when the sunscreen chemistry is clean. Their approval rate of 47% shows how often those conditions actually get met. Anyone drawn to flavored balms, camphor or menthol formulas, or oxybenzone-based lip SPFs will find Doctorly has a specific reason to steer away from each one.
Watch Doctorly say it
Every verdict here comes from a video. These are the moments themselves, each one jumping straight to the bit about that product.
- Aquaphor Lip Repair Stick Plus SunscreenSkipped itWatch at 16:52
- Carmex Classic Lip BalmSkipped itWatch at 18:13
- Sun Bum Sunscreen Lip Balm SPF 30Skipped itWatch at 10:51
- Tree Hut Sugar Lips Lip ButterSkipped itWatch at 14:33
- Tatcha Kissu Lip MaskSkipped itWatch at 6:54
- The INKEY List Tripeptide Plumping Lip BalmRated itWatch at 7:50
- Vaseline Lip Therapy OriginalRated itWatch at 19:52
- Avène Lip Balm SPFRated itWatch at 26:50
- Minimalist L-Ascorbic Acid 8% Lip Treatment with Vitamin E and GlycerineRated itWatch at 23:03
- Glossier Balm DotcomRated itWatch at 34:17
- Paula's Choice Lip SPFRated itWatch at 20:07
- EltaMD UV Lip Balm Broad-Spectrum SPF 36Rated itWatch at 19:02
About this expert
See everything Doctorly has reviewed
Expert rankings
Related guides
This guide reflects what Doctorly said across their videos about 15 products in lip, aggregated by The Guru Index. Sponsored takes are excluded. The approval rate is the share of these products they approved. It is general information, not medical advice.