


Retinol has been all over the beauty pages this autumn. Yet when the experts we follow choose an over-the-counter retinoid, many of them reach for retinal (short for retinaldehyde) instead, and one name keeps coming up: Medik8 Crystal Retinal 6, with a Guru Score of 89% across 17 experts. Here is how the two ingredients differ, what the experts say about the Medik8, and how they suggest easing in while the cold months leave skin drier than usual.





Retinal is one step closer to the form of vitamin A your skin actually uses. Nadine Baggott explains the chain: skin turns retinol esters into retinol, retinol into retinal, and retinal into retinoic acid, the active form. So retinol has two conversions to go, and retinal has one. Dr. Aleksandra Brown describes retinaldehyde as "one conversion step away from retinoic acid."
That shorter path is why the experts call retinal the stronger ingredient. No BS Beauty places it above retinol and below tretinoin, the prescription form: "It's not as strong as tretinoin, but it's the next one up." Our guides to retinaldehyde and retinol go deeper into each one.
Stronger, yes. Harsher, not necessarily, by most of our experts' accounts. Nadine Baggott says "Retinaldehyde is actually more potent than retinols but tends to be more gentle on the skin," and adds that she has had problems with retinols but never with retinaldehydes. Mad About Skin calls it one of the few times you can get better results and less sensitivity from a product.
Not everyone goes that far. Mixed Makeup found the limit of her own skin: when she tried to use Crystal Retinal 6 more than twice a week, her skin "got really sensitive to it," though still less than with tretinoin. Retinal is a retinoid, and a retinoid can still irritate.
Most of them love it. Of the 17 experts we follow who have reviewed it, 15 said yes, 1 was mixed and 1 said no, for a Guru Score of 89%. Mad About Skin calls it probably the best over-the-counter retinoid you can use, and it is still being picked now: in late October, Dr. Jenny Liu called it "the one I love and highly recommend," saying it gives a bit more benefit than over-the-counter retinol before you move to tretinoin, and that she uses it on her face, neck and hands.
Two things come up again and again. The first is the strength ladder. Dr. Shereene Idriss likes that you can raise the strength slowly rather than start aggressively, and Doctor Anne points out the range runs from Crystal Retinal 1 up to Crystal Retinal 24, so the 6 is a step on the way up, not the top. The second is how it feels. Doctor Anne, whose husband tested the over-the-counter options for her, says it has the best texture, and Mad About Skin calls it "one of the most hydrating formulas I have ever found."
Mostly the price. No BS Beauty, Doctor Anne and Mad About Skin all like the formula but call it expensive next to other retinoids, and Mad About Skin points to retinals that cost less. Dr. Vanita Rattan, the one no, goes further: she thinks Medik8 had first-mover advantage and "the market's caught up," with better products now available. There is also fragrance to weigh. Mad About Skin notes that some of the lower strengths contain it, and No BS Beauty, who likes the vanilla scent, says it is something to be aware of if your skin is very sensitive.
It is also not an acne treatment, in Dr. Jenny Liu's view: she says it is a gentle retinoid for fine lines, wrinkles, tone and texture, but acne needs a prescription. If breakouts are your main concern, it is worth talking to a doctor or pharmacist, and our piece on adapalene vs tretinoin covers what the experts say about the acne options.
Go low, go slow, and cushion it. Dr. Vanita Rattan reminds us that "vitamin A is very drying to the skin," and the experts' advice on easing in is consistent. Dr. Shereene Idriss puts it as "consistency over intensity": a few nights a week, every week, beats one strong night that leaves your face sore. Start at the lowest strength a range offers and move up as your skin adapts; with Medik8 that means one of the lower steps on the ladder, and No BS Beauty suggests the A-Game 5 before the A-Game 10 if you are newer to retinoids.
Then protect your skin barrier. No BS Beauty recommends the sandwich method: a thick moisturizer, then the retinoid, then another rich layer on top. Dr. Vanita Rattan suggests finishing with "a lovely fatty moisturizer" and not pairing it with a resurfacing acid. If your skin does get sensitive, Mad About Skin simply skips it for a couple of nights and goes back once things calm down. For a richer layer on top, see the best barrier repair creams for cold weather.
Dr. Vanita Rattan also says to avoid retinal if you are pregnant. If you are pregnant, trying to be, breastfeeding or already using a prescription treatment, check with your doctor or pharmacist before you start any retinoid.
Geek & Gorgeous A-Game 10 Retinal Serum scores higher than the Medik8, with a Guru Score of 94% across 12 experts, and is the retinal several of them name as the cheaper alternative. Dr. Vanita Rattan likes it for people with a damaged or recovering skin barrier, Dr Dray calls it well formulated and "free of common allergens and irritants," and The Budget Dermatologist calls it her favorite budget retinaldehyde. Naturium Retinaldehyde Cream Serum (84%, 9 experts, every one of them a yes) is the creamy, encapsulated option Dr. Jenny Liu describes as less irritating.
The Ordinary Retinal 0.2% Emulsion (79%, 14 experts) is the strong end of the shelf. Mad About Skin is clear that it is not for beginners and suits people already used to retinoids. If you have never used vitamin A at all, The Ordinary Retinol 0.2% in Squalane (79%, 17 experts) is the retinol April Basi and Nadine Baggott suggest starting with, though Dr. Daniel Sugai found it too oily. For the full line-up, see the best retinoids and our beginner retinol guide.
If you are new to vitamin A or your skin is easily upset, the experts start people on a gentle retinol or a low-strength retinal and build up. If you already use retinol and want more from it, many of them suggest moving to retinal, which they find stronger without being harsher. Medik8 Crystal Retinal 6, at a Guru Score of 89% across 17 experts, is the experts' long-standing pick, with 15 of its 17 experts saying yes, and Geek & Gorgeous A-Game 10 Retinal Serum (94%) is the retinal they name when price matters. In winter, whichever you pick, go slowly and keep a rich moisturizer close.