Dr. Vanita Rattan has looked at more than 10 eye care products, and her approval rate of 22% tells you she sets a high bar. Most products got a mixed take or were skipped outright. The ones she does approve tend to share a few clear traits, and the ones she skips have equally clear reasons.
What does Dr. Vanita Rattan recommend in eye care?
When she approves an eye product, it usually has an active that genuinely does something. She praised Medik8 Eye Cream for using retinal, which she says works ten times faster than retinol and is well suited to skin of colour. She also rated Versed Smooth Landing Advanced Retinoid Eye Balm for leading with fats that lock in moisture and for having no fragrance, denatured alcohol, or essential oils. MZ Skin Hydra-Lift Gold Eye Mask earned her approval for a formula built around glycerin, niacinamide, and calming panthenol, all fragrance free. Packaging matters to her too. She flags products where actives can break down before you even finish the jar.
In her words
"It's got fats first, which [...] means it's going to hold water and prevent transepidermal water loss. It's got vitamin A, but it's not an airless pump, which means you don't really know how effective the vitamin A is going to be. However, it is Na Safed, meaning no denat alcohol, no fragrance, no essential oils. And I do like it, and it's only twelve pounds, so this is one that actually is decent."
"The second ingredient here is glycerin, we have niacinamide, panthenol which is anti-inflammatory, centella asiatica which is also quite soothing on the skin. It has hydrolyzed collagen, but don't forget the collagen in here acts as a humectant rather than to actually stimulate collagen. And it's fragrance free, so I really like it."
"Retinal does work 10 times better than retinol, 10 times faster. I love retinal for skin of color. It's going to have a similar efficacy to 0.3% retinol, which is the maximum we can use in terms of retinol in the EU. This is a niacinamide safe product. It's got no drying alcohol, no fragrance, no essential oils. It's not irritating. I would give this a nice seven out of 10. It's good for beginners and for intermediates. Well done Medik8, you've done very well here."
"Some of the products I love are The Ordinary Caffeine at 5%. Caffeine is one of those mitochondrial activators that helps address hair thinning by increasing ATP and supporting the growth phase of hair follicles, leading to stronger hair strands and reducing shedding."
How many eye care products has Dr. Vanita Rattan reviewed?
Dr. Vanita Rattan has reviewed 18 eye care products, for an approval rate of 22%. 4 approved, 6 mixed, and 8 skipped.
What has Dr. Vanita Rattan skipped in eye care?
Her skips each come down to a different problem, and that mix is worth knowing. Tatcha Brightening Eye Cream lost points for containing fragrance, linalool, and limonene near the eye. She says those can cause contact dermatitis and long-term pigmentation on thin orbital skin of colour. Olay Retinol 24 Eye Cream had retinol she actually liked, but jar packaging means you cannot trust how much of it survives to do any good. Haruharu Wonder Black Rice Bakuchiol Eye Cream she described as no better than a basic moisturiser, saying bakuchiol and niacinamide alone will not address what eye creams are meant to treat. And BYOMA De-puff and Brighten Eye Gel, she said, simply does not have enough vitamin C to treat dark circles in skin of colour, so it would not deliver what it promises.
"This is something I actually really wouldn't recommend for any of you. It's a shame because actually the retinol is very good, and so far we really haven't seen vitamin A in the eye creams that are meant to help with fine lines and dark circles when surely this is meant to be the first ingredient we should be looking for. I think you just need to reformulate this. And while you're at it, if you're going to put retinol in a product, don't put it in a jar."
"It's not the actual chemistry of the skin changing. So once you wash it off, it's gone. And then unfortunately in this product is a sensitizer cluster. They put in fragrance, linalool, limonene, which is just a disaster for skin of color because it can lead to contact dermatitis and lead to more pigmentation. On thin orbital skin of color around the eye, this can lead to long-term issues. This product gets a three out of 10 at £60 from Sephora."
"This product only has bucha and niacinamide, they've called it a retinol alternative, so yes you can wear this during pregnancy but it's not going to do anything much for the eyes. It's like a moisturizer, it's like wearing a bucha moisturizer or a niacinamide moisturizer. It's just not worth it."
"This product has only three oethal ascorbic acids, so that's basically just vitamin C, which is just not strong enough to treat dark circles in skin of color. It's not gonna happen. It's hydrating, it's naive safe, but it's not going to help with the dark circles. So I just wouldn't bother wasting your money."
What should you take from Dr. Vanita Rattan's picks?
Dr. Vanita Rattan's record on eye care is a useful reality check. She is not against eye creams, but she wants real actives in stable packaging, with no irritants near skin that is already thin and sensitive. With an approval rate of 22%, she named no outright category winner here, which says as much as the individual takes do.
Watch Dr. Vanita Rattan say it
Every verdict here comes from a video. These are the moments themselves, each one jumping straight to the bit about that product.
- Olay Retinol 24 Eye CreamSkipped itWatch at 19:35
- Tatcha Brightening Eye CreamSkipped itWatch at 3:34
- Haruharu Wonder Black Rice Bakuchiol Eye CreamSkipped itWatch at 16:55
- BYOMA De-puff and Brighten Eye GelSkipped itWatch at 8:47
- Chanel Revitalizing Eye CreamSkipped itWatch at 5:12
- Ole Henriksen Banana Bright Vitamin C Eye CreamSkipped itWatch at 14:02
- RoC Retinol Correxion Line Smoothing Eye CreamSkipped itWatch at 26:36
- The INKEY List Caffeine Eye CreamSkipped itWatch at 7:41
- Versed Smooth Landing Advanced Retinoid Eye BalmRated itWatch at 4:11
- MZ Skin Hydra-Lift Gold Eye MaskRated itWatch at 9:39
- Medik8 Eye CreamRated itWatch at 29:49
- The Ordinary Caffeine Solution 5% + EGCGRated itWatch at 7:49
About this expert
See everything Dr. Vanita Rattan has reviewed
Expert rankings
Related guides
This guide reflects what Dr. Vanita Rattan said across her videos about 18 products in eye care, aggregated by The Guru Index. Sponsored takes are excluded. The approval rate is the share of these products she approved. It is general information, not medical advice.