


You scan a serum you love, and the app rates it poor. That can happen with skincare scanner apps like Yuka. Dr. Vanita Rattan made a whole video about it, called "Yuka App Is Wrecking Your Skin", and walked through the scores: "The Ordinary Salicylic Acid 2% Solution scores 45 out of 100, rated poor by the Yuka app, because of phenoxyethanol." The experts we follow see it very differently: The Ordinary Salicylic Acid 2% Solution holds a Guru Score of 78% across 12 experts. Here is why the two disagree, and what the experts say about phenoxyethanol, fragrance and chemical sunscreens.






Because one ingredient decides the score. Yuka's own help pages say a product's score is based on the highest-risk ingredient in it, and that if a high-risk ingredient is present the score is automatically red, below 25 out of 100. Ingredients are rated against risks like endocrine disruption, allergies, irritation and pollution. The page on how cosmetics are scored doesn't mention how much of an ingredient is in the product.
The experts we follow judge something else: the whole product, on skin. Does it do what it says, how does it feel, and who is it right for? So a product can be marked down by an app and still earn a high Guru Score.
Not for most people, is the view of the experts who bring it up, though a few suggest care if your skin is very sensitive. Cassandra Bankson, reviewing The Ordinary Soothing and Barrier Support Serum, puts both sides in one breath: "It's not bad, it's great that this product is preserved, but for those who are super sensitive you may want to be a little bit more cautious with it."
It's also common in the products the experts rate highest. More than 40 products with a Guru Score of 80% or more, from at least 10 experts each, list phenoxyethanol in their ingredients. Three you may know: Differin Adapalene Gel 0.1% (91%, 19 experts), which Dr. Aleksandra Brown, a board-certified dermatologist, says "might be one of the best dollar for dollar buys in all of skin care"; CeraVe PM Facial Moisturizing Lotion (89%, 19 experts), which Dr. Daniel Sugai likes for patients using acne treatments who want something lightweight; and Kiehl's Ultra Facial Cream (90%, 12 experts), "a great workhorse" for dry skin, says dermatologist Dr. Shereene Idriss.
Only if your skin doesn't like it, is the general line. Mad About Skin says it plainly: "fragrance isn't the devil in skincare. It depends on personal preference and your individual skin type." Dr. Shereene Idriss makes the same point from the other side when she explains why Vanicream leaves fragrance out: "But this doesn't come from a place of fear-mongering. People who have sensitive skin tend to get very sensitive to certain ingredients".
A scented product can still score well, though the experts who mind fragrance say so. Tatcha Dewy Skin Cream lists fragrance and holds a Guru Score of 81% across 21 experts; Dr. Aleksandra Brown calls it "by far my favorite of them all" in the range. Hyram is one of the experts who said no, and fragrance is part of his reason: "it's just expensive, luxurious, and I don't like that there's fragrance in it, but it feels nice." If fragrance has irritated your skin before, a fragrance-free option may suit you better, and a dermatologist or pharmacist can help you work out what you react to.
The dermatologists we follow keep recommending them, though not every expert likes every filter. Hyram, who is wary of some chemical filters himself, has pointed out the irony of a natural DIY routine built around Supergoop Unseen Sunscreen, a chemical formula, when natural DIY creators so often tell people to avoid chemical sunscreens "because they're toxic and dangerous".
La Roche-Posay Toleriane Double Repair Face Moisturizer SPF 30 uses chemical filters and holds a Guru Score of 85%, with all 16 of its experts saying yes. Bioré UV Aqua Rich Watery Essence SPF 50+ (83%, 12 experts) is a Japanese favorite that Dr Dray really likes, with one caveat in her own words: "if you're allergic to fragrance you would want to avoid them."
Where they do split is on specific filters. La Roche-Posay Anthelios Melt-in Milk SPF 60 (77%, 20 experts) is one of Dr. Aleksandra Brown's "personal and family's go-to sunscreens". Hyram won't recommend it, saying it "has a bunch of irritating and sensitizing chemical UV filters that I don't love".
As a first look, not a verdict. If a product is marked down, it can help to see which ingredient caused it. If it's one your skin has reacted to before, that's useful to know. If it isn't, the experts' verdicts may be a better guide to how the product performs, and you can look it up on The Guru Index to see what they made of the whole formula, with every take linked to the video it came from.