Pat McGrath Labs Eyeshadow Palettes: a Guru Score of 65%

Every take, in full

What the gurus are saying.

Every take we've logged from this product's reviews across YouTube. Click any row to watch the moment they said it.

All takes Approved takes Critical takes Mixed takes Hide sponsored

~Mixed

"I probably got a couple of Pat McGrath Labs eyeshadow palettes, the smaller ones because the big ones were like $200 maybe. They're very expensive and I'm not that great with eyeshadow. So, I'm not going to spend a whole ton on eyeshadow because I'm not very good at it."

Robert Welsh

1.11M subs

~Skip

"The quality of the eyeshadows did seem to change slightly to a point where I was like, oh, I don't know what's really happening here. I remember buying one eyeshadow palette that was like a bigger version. And everyone seemed to love it. And I was like, no, this feels different. It doesn't feel right. There's something off about the quads. And then the releases came along, Bridgerton, all this other stuff, the other motherships. And it just seemed to give us this same shade of pinky nude, reddy pinky nude. It was almost like that was happening with the eyeshadow. And you were paying quite a hefty price for a cardboard palette."

All 2 takes from Robert Welsh

PROS & CONS of PAT McGRATH LABS | Watch this before your purchase!

"They're very pricey considering the choice of what you get. Some people may not be happy or see any difference in some of the palettes themselves. I know that now, more often than not, when I do see a new launch for a Pat McGrath palette, they look very samey. There's a lot of similarities between all the palettes. I don't really want to buy anything because everything looks the same as what they released last year, or perhaps a launch looks very similar to what I already have from the brand. This was a brand that kind of started out very exciting and they delivered, but I would like to be excited by the brand again, which I'm not really."

Is Pat McGrath Labs in Trouble? Talking about the Bankruptcy news.

"The quality of the eyeshadows did seem to change slightly to a point where I was like, oh, I don't know what's really happening here. I remember buying one eyeshadow palette that was like a bigger version. And everyone seemed to love it. And I was like, no, this feels different. It doesn't feel right. There's something off about the quads. And then the releases came along, Bridgerton, all this other stuff, the other motherships. And it just seemed to give us this same shade of pinky nude, reddy pinky nude. It was almost like that was happening with the eyeshadow. And you were paying quite a hefty price for a cardboard palette."

Allie Glines

830k subs

~Approved

"I really love the Pat McGrath Eyeshadow Palettes if you want even more sparkle, glitz and glamour. Any of hers are really great."

Common questions

Frequently asked.

What is Pat McGrath Labs Eyeshadow Palettes?

Luxury eyeshadow palettes in various sizes featuring highly pigmented, sparkly shades designed for dramatic eye looks.

Is Pat McGrath Labs Eyeshadow Palettes worth it?

The gurus mostly approve it, but with enough reservations to keep it in the middle at a Guru Score of 65%.

What is Pat McGrath Labs Eyeshadow Palettes's Guru Score?

Pat McGrath Labs Eyeshadow Palettes holds a Guru Score of 65%. That is our read on how warmly the experts talk about it, based on the verdicts of 3 independent expert reviewers we have collected.

Spend less, score well