Index / NYX / Butter Gloss
NYX

Butter Gloss.

NYX
Butter Gloss
Lip

Guru Score

73%

Mixed

3 experts · Moderate agreement
3Gurus
2Yay
0Mixed
1Nay

What the gurus are saying

Allie Glines and Mixed Makeup rate it highly; Dr Dray passed. Dr Dray: "This is one of those things that got so hyped up on YouTube and on social media, and I could not have been more disappointed."
Synthesized from 3 expert reviews · most recent take August 2026

Type

Lip

Where to buy

Opens a search for this product. We do not sell anything ourselves.

More from NYX 22 products · Guru Score 86% → How it works Independent by design. Every take comes from a creator we have no relationship with. We do not ask anyone to review, and affiliate links never move a score.

What the gurus are saying.

Every take we've logged from this product's reviews across YouTube. Click any row to watch the moment they said it.

All takes Yay takes Nay takes Mixed takes Hide sponsored
Dr Dray
Dr Dray
2.68M subs
~Nay
"This is one of those things that got so hyped up on YouTube and on social media, and I could not have been more disappointed. But I understand that some of you do like this NYX Butter Gloss, so if that's you, you get four glosses, and I like that it comes with a clear, colorless one too."
All 5 takes from Dr Dray
Drugstore Skincare Favorites And New Finds!
"I found these Nyx butter glosses to be underwhelming I felt like they were far and away some of the worst lip glosses I've ever used"
*NEW* SKINCARE AT TARGET WE NEED TO DISCUSS 🛍
"So far they're pretty good but they do have flavorant in them which is like okay I didn't need that"
*NEW* Skincare Holiday Gift Sets At Target 2024
"The NYX Butter glosses I was not impressed"
Costco Skincare: What’s Actually Worth Buying? | Dermatologist Shops
"This is one of those things that got so hyped up on YouTube and on social media, and I could not have been more disappointed. But I understand that some of you do like this NYX Butter Gloss, so if that's you, you get four glosses, and I like that it comes with a clear, colorless one too."
L'Oreal....this is just bad
"I bought these NYX Butter glosses because I'd heard such good things about them, and I'm kind of disappointed. They're not bad, the color is really pretty, but they don't stay on very long, like at all. They're deeply moisturizing, these aren't drying, but they do have fragrance in them which I find annoying because it's a common irritant in lip care products. I don't necessarily need the lip gloss to smell like creme brulee, but it is an enjoyable scent, I'll give it that."
Allie Glines
Allie Glines
829k subs
~Yay
"It Glides really well it comes in a ton of different colors it just never lets me down it's not sticky it's a nice consistency Glides well"
Mixed Makeup
Mixed Makeup
1.46M subs
~Yay
"I have many many NYX Butter glasses this one is in brownie drip and I'm gonna put it over the Baby Lip for a little extra"

Frequently asked.

Is NYX Butter Gloss worth it?

The gurus mostly approve it, but with enough reservations to keep it in the middle at a Guru Score of 73%.

What is NYX Butter Gloss's Guru Score?

NYX Butter Gloss holds a Guru Score of 73%. That is our read on how warmly the experts talk about it, based on the verdicts of 3 expert reviewers we have collected.

Similar products worth a look.

Other products the same gurus have weighed in on, plus more from this brand and category.

Compare side by side →

Put this score on your own site.

Free to use, no sign-up. The badge reads live from our data, so it updates itself when the experts change their minds.

NYX Butter Gloss: a Guru Score of 73% from 3 experts on The Guru Index

This week's top beauty news, in your inbox.

A weekly read of the takes worth catching up on: the raves, the splits, the ones the gurus won't shut up about. Free, no spam, unsubscribe whenever.

Subscribe to the digest