Index / Makeup by Mario / Surreal Skin Concealer
Makeup by Mario

Makeup by Mario Surreal Skin Concealer.

Makeup by Mario Surreal Skin Concealer
Save to Pinterest
Concealer
About this product

A concealer designed to cover dark circles and blemishes with medium to full, buildable coverage and a skin-like finish.

More from Makeup by Mario 17 products · Guru Score 91% →

Guru Score

64%

Mixed

4 experts · Moderate agreement

What the gurus are saying

Pretty at 9am, a different story by afternoon: that's the split on this creamy, lightweight concealer. Fans find it natural and luminous, say it stays put, and note that a little goes a long way. Others watched it cling to dry patches and settle into lines up close. Shade matching can take work, since a perfect match meant blending two shades.
Synthesized from 4 expert reviews · most recent take November 2024

What they liked

  • Looks beautiful at first
  • Creamy, lightweight texture
  • Stays put under the eyes

What they flagged

  • Looks dry and patchy by midday
  • Settles into fine lines
  • Looks rough up close

Type

ConcealerLiquid

Where to buy

Opens a store search. We may earn from these links.

Scan it in the shopFree iPhone app. Scores in the aisle.

What the gurus are saying.

Every take we've logged from this product's reviews across YouTube. Click any row to watch the moment they said it.

All takes Yay takes Nay takes Mixed takes Hide sponsored
~Nay
"I was really disappointed by the Makeup by Mario Surreal Skin Concealer. [...] I was excited because it seemed like it would be a very skin-like concealer. [...] Upon initial application it did look really beautiful, it's the wear I had an issue with. As time went on it started to make my under eye area look dry and cling to patches, and I never have issues like that with concealer. [...] That one just didn't work out for me."
All 3 takes from Abbey Yung
Don't Buy These Products From the Sephora VIB Sale... Sephora Sale Pass & Purchase!
"I was really disappointed by the Makeup by Mario Surreal Skin Concealer. [...] I was excited because it seemed like it would be a very skin-like concealer. [...] Upon initial application it did look really beautiful, it's the wear I had an issue with. As time went on it started to make my under eye area look dry and cling to patches, and I never have issues like that with concealer. [...] That one just didn't work out for me."
ULTIMATE New Concealer Showdown! I Tried Every New Concealer (With Wear Tests) So You Don't Have To
"It's weird how it still looks good from a normal distance but [...] not amazing up close. [...] This may be one I play around with more with different eye creams or a blurring primer, since I didn't use anything that could manipulate the finish this time, but for now it's not the best."
I Tried All The New Beauty Launches & Viral Products So You Don't Have To... Part 1!
"But as the day went on it started [...] patching up a bit, clinging in areas, looking dry in certain spots, and it did slightly settle into lines. [...] Up close [...] it didn't look great, it definitely didn't hold up in the way that the brand claimed it would, so I totally get why people are not loving this, which is a big bummer because that initial application I thought was super pretty."
~Nay
"By the way I hated this concealer the makeup by mario concealer I was going to do like a video on it and I just ended up absolutely hating it"
~Yay
"We'll see if I can use it on the skin, I'm not sure, like over blemishes and stuff. I'm just gonna do that much. [...] Coverage is nice, and I was wondering if it would have the same sort of luminosity that the Makeup by Mario foundation has. I definitely feel like it does. So here's the before and after on that. I feel like it really has nice coverage and kind of has a bit of luminosity, which is nice, but it's not like a runny concealer, so it seems like it might have some longevity to it."
~Yay
"If you don't really need to cover your under eyes, go with Makeup by Mario. It still has coverage but it's very creamy and very lightweight."
Sponsored
All 8 takes from Ali Andreea
Sephora makeup recommendations 2024 | ALI ANDREEA
"If you don't really need to cover your under eyes, go with Makeup by Mario. It still has coverage but it's very creamy and very lightweight."
NEW makeup routine for my tired skin | ALI ANDREEA
"This quickly got on my list of favorite concealers at the moment. It's so good. Good products are only getting better and better. I feel it's not going to be great for everyone, of course, but as far as I'm concerned this is a great concealer for my under eyes."
I've tried countless makeup looks, this is what works best on me | ALI ANDREEA
"I love this concealer because it's just so natural on me."
This is how I did Taylor Hills's makeup in Cannes | ALI ANDREEA
"I love how this concealer stays put. It's really remarkable. There are many remarkable concealers on the market right now, I just love this one."
Realistic, everyday makeup tutorial with guest Kate Brian | ALI ANDREEA
"We're going to use Makeup by Mario concealer, and that's also because Kate hasn't tried it, and I'm like you have to. You should have heard her gasp just a little bit."
The only makeup I'm wearing this spring | ALI ANDREEA
"This concealer from Makeup by Mario, again, this is a super nice, reliable concealer. A little goes a long way."
This is the Christmas makeup look anyone can do | ALI ANDREEA
"I just bought this concealer. I used it yesterday for the first time and I love it, but [...] obviously I had so many concealers I didn't need another one. [...] If you have a concealer that you are happy with, you don't need a new one."
Best makeup in 2023 | ALI ANDREEA
"This is a really, really good concealer. [...] I couldn't find my perfect shade on Makeup by Mario, to get the right shade I have to mix 160 with 180, so that's a little downside for me."

Frequently asked.

What is Makeup by Mario Surreal Skin Concealer?

A concealer designed to cover dark circles and blemishes with medium to full, buildable coverage and a skin-like finish.

Is Makeup by Mario Surreal Skin Concealer worth it?

The gurus are split. 2 of the 4 gurus give it their stamp of approval while 2 would skip it, which lands it in the middle at a Guru Score of 64%.

What is Makeup by Mario Surreal Skin Concealer's Guru Score?

Makeup by Mario Surreal Skin Concealer holds a Guru Score of 64%. That is our read on how warmly the experts talk about it, based on the verdicts of 4 expert reviewers we have collected.

Who is Makeup by Mario Surreal Skin Concealer best for?

Makeup by Mario Surreal Skin Concealer is generally suited to oily skin, dry skin, combination skin, normal skin and acne-prone skin.

Cheaper alternatives the gurus rate.

Lower-priced concealers the gurus still rate highly, versus this mid-range pick.

See how they stack up →

Also on the gurus' radar.

Other products the same gurus have weighed in on, plus more from this brand and category.

Compare side by side →

Spotted something on this page that doesn't look right? Let us know.

Share this score

Add this badge to your blog or website. It links back to this page and updates itself when the experts change their minds. Free, no sign-up.

Then paste it into your site's HTML or embed block.

The Extract

All of the week's hottest skincare news, delivered straight to your inbox. The viral products, the hot takes, and top tips from the experts.

Sign me up