Index / Makeup by Mario / Eyeliner
Makeup by Mario

Makeup by Mario Eyeliner.

Makeup by Mario Eyeliner
Save to Pinterest
Eye Makeup
About this product

A brown pencil eyeliner designed to define the lash line and add dimension to the eye area.

More from Makeup by Mario 17 products · Guru Score 91% →

Guru Score

81%

Yay

Early verdict · Few reviews so far

What the gurus are saying

This eyeliner earns consistent praise for its rich brown shade and impressive staying power. Gurus highlight how well it holds up throughout the day without creasing, and how the precise application along the lash line brightens the eye and makes lids appear larger. It's a standout choice if you're looking for one reliable eyeliner to keep in your Sephora rotation.
Synthesized from 3 expert reviews · most recent take October 2026

What they liked

  • Creases resistant, excellent staying power
  • Smooth application along lash line
  • Flattering deep brown shade

What they flagged

    Nothing. None of the experts who reviewed it raised a problem.

    Type

    Eye MakeupPencil

    Where to buy

    Opens a store search. We may earn from these links.

    Scan it in the shopFree iPhone app. Scores in the aisle.

    What the gurus are saying.

    Every take we've logged from this product's reviews across YouTube. Click any row to watch the moment they said it.

    All takes Yay takes Nay takes Mixed takes Hide sponsored
    ✓Yay
    "If I had to pick just one eyeliner to buy from Sephora it would be this one, the Makeup by Mario eyeliner in the shade The Perfect Brown. It's so good. It looks intense like a black but obviously it's not, so it leaves a really beautiful soft yet intense definition to the eyes. [...] It's obviously a very very dark brown but it gives beautiful definition to the eye area."
    All 4 takes from Allie Glines
    FULL FACE OF MAKEUP BY MARIO...
    "I'm going to go in with the Makeup by Mario eyeliner and this is in the shade the perfect brown. I'm going to take this and go right up against the lash line. It's a really pretty kind of deep brown. And I'm actually going to take a little smudgy brush and mix the black with this brown right here and create a little bit of like a shadowing on top of that liner just to kind of smudge things out a bit."
    EVERYONE gets 20% OFF at Sephora right now?!
    "If I had to pick just one eyeliner to buy from Sephora it would be this one, the Makeup by Mario eyeliner in the shade The Perfect Brown. It's so good. It looks intense like a black but obviously it's not, so it leaves a really beautiful soft yet intense definition to the eyes. [...] It's obviously a very very dark brown but it gives beautiful definition to the eye area."
    The ONLY Makeup I Need Right Now...
    "I'm going to take this Makeup by Mario pencil in the shade Perfect Brown and just add some more dimension right up against that lash line."
    What I Bought at Sephora This Week.. 🙈
    "This one, though, is [...] a little bit wobbly, and I might have got a defective one. This one feels like it dried out. The color really is so nice, but it's super dry. I just know this because I use the other color, so I think what I'll do is probably exchange this for another one. [...] I'll try it in another video. The color looks nice, and I am really excited about that, and I do want to try it. I just feel like mine dried out."
    ✓Yay
    "This is a really beautiful, warm, caramelly kind of brown. I'm just going to place this all in my waterline. This will depend on your eye shape. You can just keep it in your waterline, but if I have quite a shelf from my waterline and I just put it there, it leaves a gap for the rest of my lash line. So what I do is place it in my waterline and then angle the pencil and go from my waterline against my lash line, so that a little bit is getting onto my lash line."
    All 3 takes from Alexandra Anele
    Emma’s makeup is perfect
    "I'm going to start off with the Makeup by Mario [...] eyeliner, in the shade the perfect brown. [...] I'm going to start off with this in my waterline and right at the top, my tightlining, just pushing this into my lashes."
    The perfect fall makeup my friends
    "This is a really beautiful, warm, caramelly kind of brown. I'm just going to place this all in my waterline. This will depend on your eye shape. You can just keep it in your waterline, but if I have quite a shelf from my waterline and I just put it there, it leaves a gap for the rest of my lash line. So what I do is place it in my waterline and then angle the pencil and go from my waterline against my lash line, so that a little bit is getting onto my lash line."
    How to look gorg when you’ve been crying
    "I'm going to use the brown eyeliner from Makeup by Mario, just going to dot it on the outer part. [...] I'm creating a line going straight out rather than it dipping down. I'm going to use a little brush that's in here and pat that into the lash line so I'm not creating a wing, I'm not making it super smoky. I'm literally just kind of defining and deepening that outer part of that lash line and then I'm just going to pat and fade."
    ✓Yay
    "These eyeshadows from Makeup by Mario. I'm actually wearing the shade taupe right now. These are the most long-lasting. It's a brand created by a makeup artist. [...] Both of these are very good, but [...] Makeup by Mario will last definitely better than Armani."
    Sponsored
    All 2 takes from Ali Andreea
    Beginner Makeup Starter Kit | Simple Makeup for People Afraid of Makeup | ANDREEA ALI
    "This is what I have on my eyes, by the way, the Makeup by Mario. It's far more pigmented and opaque than the Armani tint, which is a style a true minimalist might be scared of using. It has really good performance."
    Watch This Before You Shop the Sephora Sale | ANDREEA ALI
    "These eyeshadows from Makeup by Mario. I'm actually wearing the shade taupe right now. These are the most long-lasting. It's a brand created by a makeup artist. [...] Both of these are very good, but [...] Makeup by Mario will last definitely better than Armani."

    Frequently asked.

    What is Makeup by Mario Eyeliner?

    A brown pencil eyeliner designed to define the lash line and add dimension to the eye area.

    Is Makeup by Mario Eyeliner worth it?

    Yes. All 3 gurus who reviewed it give it their stamp of approval, for a Guru Score of 81%.

    What is Makeup by Mario Eyeliner's Guru Score?

    Makeup by Mario Eyeliner holds a Guru Score of 81%. That is our read on how warmly the experts talk about it, based on the verdicts of 3 expert reviewers we have collected.

    Cheaper alternatives the gurus rate.

    Lower-priced eye makeup the gurus still rate highly, versus this mid-range pick.

    See how they stack up →

    Also on the gurus' radar.

    Other products the same gurus have weighed in on, plus more from this brand and category.

    Compare side by side →

    Spotted something on this page that doesn't look right? Let us know.

    Share this score

    Add this badge to your blog or website. It links back to this page and updates itself when the experts change their minds. Free, no sign-up.

    Then paste it into your site's HTML or embed block.

    The Extract

    All of the week's hottest skincare news, delivered straight to your inbox. The viral products, the hot takes, and top tips from the experts.

    Sign me up