Index / Maison Margiela / Replica By the Fireplace
Maison Margiela

Replica By the Fireplace.

Maison Margiela
Replica By the Fireplace

Guru Score

84%

Yay

Early verdict · Few reviews so far
2Gurus
2Yay
0Mixed
0Nay

What the gurus are saying

Unanimous yay from 2 reviewers. The Style and Beauty Doctor and Allie Glines both rate it highly. Top take: "I actually like the way that this smells on me. [...] When I cuz I have By the Fireplace, one of my favorites. Maybe that's why I like this one. I do find this to be a little... [...] The By the Fireplace is an EDT.", The Style and Beauty Doctor.
Synthesized from 2 expert reviews · most recent take November 2025

Where to buy

Opens a search for this product. We do not sell anything ourselves.

More from Maison Margiela 2 products · Guru Score 92% → How it works Independent by design. Every take comes from a creator we have no relationship with. We do not ask anyone to review, and affiliate links never move a score.

What the gurus are saying.

Every take we've logged from this product's reviews across YouTube. Click any row to watch the moment they said it.

All takes Yay takes Nay takes Mixed takes Hide sponsored
The Style and Beauty Doctor
The Style and Beauty Doctor
221k subs
✓Yay
"I actually like the way that this smells on me. [...] When I cuz I have By the Fireplace, one of my favorites. Maybe that's why I like this one. I do find this to be a little... [...] The By the Fireplace is an EDT. [...] It does smell very similar to By the Fireplace except I feel like this is a little softer and more feminine. I think I could agree with that. I did wear it the other day and I kind of feel like it needs, you know, for you to spray a lot."
All 3 takes from The Style and Beauty Doctor
My People Tell Me THE TRUTH About My Fave Fall/Winter Fragrances
"I actually like the way that this smells on me. [...] When I cuz I have By the Fireplace, one of my favorites. Maybe that's why I like this one. I do find this to be a little... [...] The By the Fireplace is an EDT. [...] It does smell very similar to By the Fireplace except I feel like this is a little softer and more feminine. I think I could agree with that. I did wear it the other day and I kind of feel like it needs, you know, for you to spray a lot."
They TRIED IT w these Fall Fragrance Launches (Kayali, Miu Miu, Phlur)
"By the Fireplace is a masterpiece. It smells like a jazz club, so it has that little tobacco. It has a little booziness to it. [...] I did end up liking that eventually."
Forcing Myself to Wear ALL of My Perfumes 😩
"Oh my god I love this It's a very like smoky kind of scent I love it"
Allie Glines
Allie Glines
829k subs
✓Yay
"The Replica By the Fireplace that is what this look smells like to me okay oh oh my gosh it's been so long since I've worn this it's my favorite fall fragrance"

Frequently asked.

Is Maison Margiela Replica By the Fireplace worth it?

Yes. All 2 gurus who reviewed it give it their stamp of approval, for a Guru Score of 84%.

What is Maison Margiela Replica By the Fireplace's Guru Score?

Maison Margiela Replica By the Fireplace holds a Guru Score of 84%. That is our read on how warmly the experts talk about it, based on the verdicts of 2 expert reviewers we have collected.

Similar products worth a look.

Other products the same gurus have weighed in on, plus more from this brand and category.

Compare side by side →

Put this score on your own site.

Free to use, no sign-up. The badge reads live from our data, so it updates itself when the experts change their minds.

Maison Margiela Replica By the Fireplace: a Guru Score of 84% from 2 experts on The Guru Index

This week's top beauty news, in your inbox.

A weekly read of the takes worth catching up on: the raves, the splits, the ones the gurus won't shut up about. Free, no spam, unsubscribe whenever.

Subscribe to the digest