Chestnut Lip Liner.

Lip

The Guru Index verdict

76%

Approved

✓Approved · 76% 2 independent gurus · Early signal

2Reviewers

1Approved

1Mixed

0Skip

◆ Independent by design. Every take comes from a creator we have no relationship with. We do not ask anyone to review, and affiliate links never move a score. How it works

What the gurus are saying

Dr Sam Bunting rate it; The Style and Beauty Doctor is mixed. The dissent from The Style and Beauty Doctor: "MAC Chestnut lip liner, which is a dark brown, and then old baby lip gloss, which is a clear lip gloss with gold sparkle…"

Synthesized from 2 expert reviews · most recent take March 2025

Where to buy

Amazon Shop → Google Shopping Shop →

Every take, in full

What the gurus are saying.

Every take we've logged from this product's reviews across YouTube. Click any row to watch the moment they said it.

All takes Approved only Skip only Mixed only Hide sponsored

Dr Sam Bunting

240k subs

✓Approved

"Not many people have done a great chocolate brown pencil. MAC have done a good one called Chestnut, which is a staple in many dark skinned black girls' makeup bags."

The Style and Beauty Doctor

220k subs · 6k devotees

~Mixed

"MAC Chestnut lip liner, which is a dark brown, and then old baby lip gloss, which is a clear lip gloss with gold sparkle, very iridescent, very shiny. That combo was so overdone that I remember because I was on some makeup message boards back in the mid to late 2000s where people were like, 'Yo, we got to put a moratorium on the old baby lip gloss and the MAC Chestnut lip liner. We need to like cease and desist.'"

Common questions

Frequently asked.

Is MAC Chestnut Lip Liner worth it?

Dr Sam Bunting rate it; The Style and Beauty Doctor is mixed. The dissent from The Style and Beauty Doctor: "MAC Chestnut lip liner, which is a dark brown, and then old baby lip gloss, which is a clear lip gloss with gold sparkle…"

What is MAC Chestnut Lip Liner's Guru Score?

MAC Chestnut Lip Liner holds a Guru Score of 76 out of 100. That is our read on how warmly the experts talk about it, based on the verdicts of 2 independent expert reviewers we have collected.

Spend less, score well