Index / Lisa Eldridge / Something Brown Coffee Brown Eyeliner
Lisa Eldridge

Something Brown Coffee Brown Eyeliner.

Lisa Eldridge Something Brown Coffee Brown Eyeliner
Eye Makeup

About this product

A creamy pencil eyeliner by Lisa Eldridge available in shades including Coffee Brown, designed for blending and lining the lash line.

Guru Score

84%

Yay

3 experts · Moderate agreement
3Gurus
3Yay
0Mixed
0Nay

What they liked

  • Creamy, blendable texture
  • Easy to apply along lash line
  • Good working time before setting

What they flagged

  • Not waterproof, may smudge on waterline

What the gurus are saying

The creaminess and blendability are what keep coming up, these liners glide on easily and soften beautifully along the lash line, giving a smudged, natural look rather than a sharp line. Gurus praise the working time, which means you can position and blend without rush. One caveat: it's not waterproof, so anyone who needs serious staying power in the waterline may want to reach for a waterproof formula instead, though the smudgy texture makes it wonderful for that intentional smoky effect.
Synthesized from 3 expert reviews · most recent take September 2026

What the gurus are saying.

Every take we've logged from this product's reviews across YouTube. Click any row to watch the moment they said it.

All takes Yay takes Nay takes Mixed takes Hide sponsored
Yay
"I'm starting with the Lisa Eldridge black trile eyeliner. This is my favorite because it's extremely creamy, so it's very, very blendable. The Lisa Eldridge liners really give you like work work time, so you don't need to panic."
All 9 takes from Alexandra Anele
Zendaya can do no wrong
"I'm going to use Lisa Eldridge Black because it's just so easy to blend. This is a product that is very creamy and easy to blend and work with, but it will set down eventually."
These are my FAVORITE Lisa Eldridge Products
"I've had these since they launched and they have never dried out ever. The cap creates this suction that really seals the product in. I know there are a lot of people who complain about other nice creamy eyeliners eventually drying out, but this one just chills. The shade I'm wearing today is Black Trickle, and I used it to thicken up my lash line. The pigment is incredible. It's so soft, so blendable, so easy to blend out. It gives you such a beautiful blending time, and then it will set down. It's like a creamy coal. It works really nicely underneath shadows if you're trying to create depth. It's just so beautiful. I love it so much."
How to get Sabrina Carpenter’s ‘Soft Baddie’ makeup look
"This eyeliner is so easy to blend, like it's so incredibly creamy. I'm placing this kind of in my tight line, really tight against my lash line, [...] and then [...] blending it [...] because it really just looks like such an extension of the lashes."
Here’s the makeup look you asked forrrrr!
"So creamy."
Make your eyes POP | Tips for Hooded Eye TOO
"I'm going to go along my lash line with Lisa Eldridge ground coffee, making it a little thicker on the outer corner but then kind of just tight lining for the rest of the lash line. Then I'm going to buff a little bit with the E21 smudge brush from Sigma. I'm going to take that same skin shadow, the chocolatey brown on that same brush and just press that into that liner, kind of just creating a wing like straight out but really really soft."
Em Rata’s hot and so are U
"This Lisa Eldridge charcoal pencil, it's in the shade black trial. If you want something that's going to really last in your waterline, then perhaps use something waterproof. This is very much like a smudgy kind of coal pencil, which is great, it's fantastic for blending. But I don't know if I necessarily notice it like leaving my waterline and stuff. It pretty much stayed there."
The difference a tightline makes is crazy
"I'm actually going to be using Lisa Eldridge Black... This is a coal pencil. It's super super creamy and it glides beautifully, but it does have a really nice wear time. It stays put."
These brands are doing it RIGHT
"The eyeliners have such blendability and quality. If you haven't tried something from Lisa Eldridge, you absolutely must."
Britney's makeup was ICONIC
"I'm starting with the Lisa Eldridge black trile eyeliner. This is my favorite because it's extremely creamy, so it's very, very blendable. The Lisa Eldridge liners really give you like work work time, so you don't need to panic."
Yay
"I love Lisa Eldridge eyeliners. For me, the number one rule is creamy. There's so many that get stuck on your eyelid, and you're like, it's like I know there was a crease there. There's no need to point it out like as you're drawing it. You know, you want something really creamy that's going to glide. You can gently blend if you want to."
All 3 takes from Caroline Hirons
Chats with C: Sarah Jossel - Sunday Times Beauty Director-At-Large | Caroline Hirons
"I love Lisa Eldridge eyeliners. For me, the number one rule is creamy. There's so many that get stuck on your eyelid, and you're like, it's like I know there was a crease there. There's no need to point it out like as you're drawing it. You know, you want something really creamy that's going to glide. You can gently blend if you want to."
Glad We Had This Chat Takes New York - Katie Jane Hughes
"Lisa Eldridge eyeliner pencils are amazing. I love them so much. They're so creamy and glidey, and really good for your kit, editorial kit and for your personal kit."
S2 Ep22: GLAD WE HAD THIS CHAT TAKES NEW YORK: Katie Jane Hughes
"Lisa Eldridge eyeliner pencils are amazing. I love them so much. They're so creamy and glidey, and really good for your kit, editorial kit and for your personal kit."
Yay
"This is Lisa Eldridge eye pencil in Cinder smoke this is like the gray"

Frequently asked.

What is Lisa Eldridge Something Brown Coffee Brown Eyeliner?

A creamy pencil eyeliner by Lisa Eldridge available in shades including Coffee Brown, designed for blending and lining the lash line.

Is Lisa Eldridge Something Brown Coffee Brown Eyeliner worth it?

Yes. All 3 gurus who reviewed it give it their stamp of approval, for a Guru Score of 84%.

What is Lisa Eldridge Something Brown Coffee Brown Eyeliner's Guru Score?

Lisa Eldridge Something Brown Coffee Brown Eyeliner holds a Guru Score of 84%. That is our read on how warmly the experts talk about it, based on the verdicts of 3 expert reviewers we have collected.

Cheaper alternatives the gurus rate.

Lower-priced eye makeup the gurus still rate highly, versus this luxury pick.

See how they stack up →

Similar products worth a look.

Other products the same gurus have weighed in on, plus more from this brand and category.

Compare side by side →

Share this score

Add this badge to your blog or website. It links back to this page and updates itself when the experts change their minds. Free, no sign-up.

Then paste it into your site's HTML or embed block.

This week's top beauty news, in your inbox.

A weekly read of the takes worth catching up on: the raves, the splits, the ones the gurus won't shut up about. Free, no spam, unsubscribe whenever.

Subscribe to the digest