L'Oreal Shadow Stick Twinkling Rose: a Guru Score of 79%

What the experts use it for.

The concerns the experts tie this product to, in their own words. Paid and founder takes don't count.

What the gurus are saying.

Every take we've logged from this product's reviews across YouTube. Click any row to watch the moment they said it.

All takes Yay takes Nay takes Mixed takes Hide sponsored

Skin Obsessed Mary

33k subs

✓Mixed

"I love the form factor. I think they're easy to apply. Don't know if I love them. I don't think this is sparkly enough. And I'm not sure if this is dark enough, but in the end, I might end up loving it. I think I'm going to come back and love this."

HotandFlashy

1.23M subs

✓Yay

"These are an eye shadow stick. These are from L'Oreal. These are the Lush Shadow Sticks. I liked them so much I reviewed them twice this year. [...] I must really, really like these. They come in mattes. They come in shimmers. [...] This formula is so good. They're so creamy. They just glide over the eyelids. They're so easy to blend. They don't dry super fast. You can blend them with your fingers or you can blend them with a brush. These have a cooling minty sensation when you put them on."

All 5 takes from HotandFlashy

Faves + Fails | Hot Tools, New Makeup, Micro-Infusion | March 2026

"They have almost like a lip plumper type minty tingle to them. I know it's meant to be like a cooling sensation when you put them on your eyes, which is fine if you don't have sensitive skin around your eyes. And when I use them on my eyelids above my eyes, it's fine. But I do love to use a taupe chubby eyeshadow stick as my [...] lower lash line liner. And I made the mistake of using the L'Oreal one there and oh my gosh, my eyes started watering and burning."

Faves + Fails! BEST Makeup, Skincare, + Travel Essentials! August 2025

"What I love so much about the L'Oreal is that it is one of the only eye crayons that I've used that you don't have to use an eyelid primer with it to get it to last all day and not settle in your crease."

Best Makeup of 2025 for Mature Skin! Drugstore to High End

"These are an eye shadow stick. These are from L'Oreal. These are the Lush Shadow Sticks. I liked them so much I reviewed them twice this year. [...] I must really, really like these. They come in mattes. They come in shimmers. [...] This formula is so good. They're so creamy. They just glide over the eyelids. They're so easy to blend. They don't dry super fast. You can blend them with your fingers or you can blend them with a brush. These have a cooling minty sensation when you put them on."

Testing NEW *DRUGSTORE* Makeup 2025! NEW Elf, L'Oreal, NYX & More | Over 50!

"I really liked these L'Oreal eyeshadow sticks. They were really creamy, really easy to blend. They didn't dry out my eyelids, but they also didn't last the entire day either. [...] They've settled into my crease. I love that they have a nice midtone matte that you can use to disguise the hood and put it in your crease, or you can do your whole eye with it. It's really pretty, kind of a pinkish mauve grayish color."

Testing **ALL NEW DRUGSTORE** Multitasking Makeup! Wear Test + Review

"Really like this L'Oreal Shadow Stick. This is awesome. Stayed in place all day. No settling in my crease without using a primer. This one's a really pretty color. Love the eyeshadow stick. Highly recommend this. I think this is probably one of the best eyeshadow sticks that I've used. And I think I'm going to go out and get a couple more of these."

Dr Dray

2.69M subs

✓Yay

"Day 13 is the shadow stick in shade twinkling rose."

Sincerely Miss Ash

196k subs

✓Yay

"If you guys haven't tried the L'Oreal Shadow Sticks you are truly missing out, these are phenomenal. [...] I feel like these are better and very comparable to some of the formulations and products like this that you find at Sephora. [...] I think that this is better than the Laura Mercier formulation. These glide on like butter, they have a long wear time and you can create so many different looks with these."

Alexandra Anele

1.45M subs

✓Yay

"For my eyeshadow I'm going to be trying once again from L'Oreal the Shadow Sticks, this one is in the shade Twinkling Rose. They're kind of like rounded like this and I'm hoping that they're easy to blend. [...] It feels kind of cooling and then I'm just going to pat it out. [...] I'm just going to be interested to see how it wears."

What the evidence says.

Independent of what the gurus think, this is what the published research supports about the main active ingredients here.

Frequently asked.

What is L'Oreal Shadow Stick Twinkling Rose?

A creamy, twist-up eyeshadow stick from L'Oreal in the shade Twinkling Rose, designed to glide onto lids and blend into a wash of color.

Is L'Oreal Shadow Stick Twinkling Rose worth it?

Mostly yes. 4 of the 5 gurus who reviewed it give it their stamp of approval, for a Guru Score of 79%.

What is L'Oreal Shadow Stick Twinkling Rose's Guru Score?

L'Oreal Shadow Stick Twinkling Rose holds a Guru Score of 79%. That is our read on how warmly the experts talk about it, based on the verdicts of 5 expert reviewers we have collected.