Essence Stay and Play Gel Eyeliner: a Guru Score of 84%

What the gurus are saying.

Every take we've logged from this product's reviews across YouTube. Click any row to watch the moment they said it.

All takes Yay takes Nay takes Mixed takes Hide sponsored

HotandFlashy

1.23M subs

✓Yay

"My favorite everyday eyeliner that I tried this year is from Essence."

All 2 takes from HotandFlashy

Best Makeup of 2025 for Mature Skin! Drugstore to High End

"My favorite everyday eyeliner that I tried this year is from Essence."

Faves + Fails March 2025

"I tried an Essence eyeliner in that video and love this this is their stay andplay gel eyeliner it's long lasting and waterproof"

Alexandra Anele

1.44M subs

✓Yay

"It's quite creamy and easy to blend."

All 2 takes from Alexandra Anele

Holiday Glam using ALL Drugstore Makeup

"It's quite creamy and easy to blend."

Make Small Eyes POP | A ridiculously in depth tutorial

"One of my favorites is the stay stay in play from Essence which is a beautiful like bright nude"

What the evidence says.

Independent of what the gurus think, this is what the published research supports about the main active ingredients here.

Frequently asked.

Is Essence Stay and Play Gel Eyeliner worth it?

Yes. All 2 gurus who reviewed it give it their stamp of approval, for a Guru Score of 84%.

What is Essence Stay and Play Gel Eyeliner's Guru Score?

Essence Stay and Play Gel Eyeliner holds a Guru Score of 84%. That is our read on how warmly the experts talk about it, based on the verdicts of 2 expert reviewers we have collected.

Cheaper alternatives the gurus rate.

Lower-priced products in the same category that the experts still rate highly.

See how they stack up →

Similar products worth a look.

Other products the same gurus have weighed in on, plus more from this brand and category.

Compare side by side →

Essence

Lash Without Limits Mascara in Brown

68% 4 reviewers

Rare Beauty

Perfect Strokes Universal Volumizing Mascara

76% 10 reviewers

Anastasia Beverly Hills

Brow Freeze

66% 10 reviewers

Makeup by Mario

Master Mattes The Neutrals Eyeshadow Palette

91% 5 reviewers

This product, in the news.

Stories where our editors dug into this product or its brand.

Put this score on your own site.

Free to use, no sign-up. The badge reads live from our data, so it updates itself when the experts change their minds.

Copy this HTML

<a href="https://theguruindex.com/product/essence-stay-and-play-gel-eyeliner" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
  <img src="https://theguruindex.com/badge/essence-stay-and-play-gel-eyeliner.svg" alt="Essence Stay and Play Gel Eyeliner: a Guru Score of 84% from 2 experts on The Guru Index" width="320" height="64">
</a>

Stay and Play Gel Eyeliner.

84%