Every take, in full
What the gurus are saying.
Every take we've logged from this product's reviews across YouTube. Click any row to watch the moment they said it.
All takes
Approved only
Skip only
Mixed only
Hide sponsored
~Mixed
"This one by E.L.F. is $8, and you guys did not stop talking about it. I had to try it because that price is unbeatable. Can't beat the price for sure. It looked nice on the skin. It was a little clumpy for me, but maybe that's a personal thing, like how sometimes skincare pills on some people and not on others. Honestly, for $8, it's really hard to beat. Something to consider."
✓Approved
"The e.l.f. mascara got a five out of five for application, it separated each lash and they looked really nice. The appearance also got a five out of five. I love this for a more natural look. The Milani was more spiky and shiny whereas the e.l.f. was a little bit more natural looking and it definitely extended my lashes. As far as smudging, it did smudge a touch and got a three out of five. For washability, it did not do well, it took a lot for me to get this off, it wasn't easy to wash off, and it didn't necessarily come off in exact tubes, so it also got a two out of five for wash off."
