Carmex Classic Lip Balm: a Guru Score of 58% from 4 experts

What the gurus are saying.

Every take we've logged from this product's reviews across YouTube. Click any row to watch the moment they said it.

All takes Yay takes Nay takes Mixed takes Hide sponsored

~Yay

"I'm currently back on the yellow tube Carmex. Back on the Carmex, hard to go wrong with the Carmex. The only thing I don't like about Carmex is the round applicator because it still got the round one. I would like a triangular shape. I've tried like the expensive ones, I've tried the very expensive lava ones and all of those really expensive ones for this, but like a cheap Carmex does the job. Yeah, it's pretty much the same. I don't want to put my finger in an expensive pot. I just want to put it on and it's done."

All 2 takes from Caroline Hirons

S2 Ep15: Charlene White

"I'm currently back on the yellow tube Carmex. Hard to go wrong with a bit of Carmex. The only thing I don't like about Carmex is the round applicator because it's still got the round one. I would like a triangular shape so it hits the lip very detailed. I've tried like the expensive ones, I've tried the very expensive Lav P one and all of those like really expensive ones, but like a cheaper Carmex is pretty much the same. I don't want to put my finger in an expensive pot. I just want to put it on and it's done."

Glad We Had This Chat - Charlene White

"I'm currently back on the yellow tube Carmex. Back on the Carmex, hard to go wrong with the Carmex. The only thing I don't like about Carmex is the round applicator because it still got the round one. I would like a triangular shape. I've tried like the expensive ones, I've tried the very expensive lava ones and all of those really expensive ones for this, but like a cheap Carmex does the job. Yeah, it's pretty much the same. I don't want to put my finger in an expensive pot. I just want to put it on and it's done."

Doctorly

3.58M subs

~Nay

"If you're in a situation where you went skiing or you got a sunburn, that Carmex numbing sensation is going to give you some relief for some time, but in the background you're going to be dealing with a low level of inflammation from the common allergens, flavors, fragrances in this product. This will give you temporary relief, which is addicting to get temporary relief just like painkillers can become addicting. I would avoid this product. I would never use this again."

Dr Dray

2.68M subs

~Nay

"CarX has ingredients that are soothing like camper phenol but also irritating. The CarX, uh, you put it on, it feels soothing, it feels like your lips are soft because it is moisturizing, but then you get that irritation that develops, uh, and several hours later you're like, oh, my lips are chapped again. So you reach for more CarX. Say vicious cycle."

All 4 takes from Dr Dray

DARK PATCHES AROUND THE MOUTH EXPLAINED | Dermatologist

"Carmex has camphor in it that may feel soothing on application but ultimately can be pretty irritating to the skin of the lips."

How To Get Hydrated Lips FAST | Dermatologist Tips

"CarX has ingredients that are soothing like camper phenol but also irritating. The CarX, uh, you put it on, it feels soothing, it feels like your lips are soft because it is moisturizing, but then you get that irritation that develops, uh, and several hours later you're like, oh, my lips are chapped again. So you reach for more CarX. Say vicious cycle."

Drugstore Skincare Gems You Need To Know About!

"Carmex Classic Lip Balm is a notorious product for causing irritant dermatitis because while it's got the good white petrolatum, it also has camphor, menthol, salicylic acid, and phenol which feel really soothing going on but then are super irritating to the delicate lip skin. And so then an irritation develops, so what do you do? You reach for more and the cycle repeats itself."

Sunscreen Empties

"Carmex is a lip balm that people love and adore, but it has ingredients that commonly irritate the lips, and they commonly do so in a somewhat delayed fashion, leading to a disconnect. The user applies Carmex and it feels good, Carmex has a very soothing property to it by virtue of ingredients like camphor, but then those ingredients cause irritation that shows up later, so the user thinks they need more Carmex to help their irritated lips, and the cycle repeats itself."

Hyram

4.34M subs

~Mixed

"I remember always hating how glossy this lip balm made my lips look, but nowadays give me the gloss baby, I could definitely use more glossy lips. The texture, the smell, oh the nostalgia. It definitely feels glossy, but the shine isn't too intense. It has menthol in it, which leaves that cooling sensation that a lot of people like, but it can be irritating to the skin. Overall, am I totally opposed to it on the lips? No, but it's not my favorite thing in the world."

What the evidence says.

Independent of what the gurus think, this is what the published research supports about the main active ingredients here.

Salicylic acid

Salicylic acid dissolves in oil, so it can get into a pore rather than just working on the surface. That is why it has long-standing evidence for blackheads and milder acne.

Source: DermNet

Frequently asked.

What is Carmex Classic Lip Balm?

A classic medicated lip balm in a yellow tube, formulated with camphor and menthol to moisturize and protect lips.

Is Carmex Classic Lip Balm worth it?

The gurus are split. 1 of the 4 gurus give it their stamp of approval while 2 would skip it, which lands it in the middle at a Guru Score of 58%.

What is Carmex Classic Lip Balm's Guru Score?

Carmex Classic Lip Balm holds a Guru Score of 58%. That is our read on how warmly the experts talk about it, based on the verdicts of 4 expert reviewers we have collected.