Index/ News/Ingredients
Ingredients

Niacinamide vs vitamin C: what the experts say

The experts lean to niacinamide, mostly because vitamin C is fussier to keep working. Vitamin C still has more proof for sun-damaged skin, and the two work well together.
Save to Pinterest
Minimalist productNaturium productBubble product

Niacinamide comes out ahead with the experts we track, but not because vitamin C fails to work. Niacinamide has a Guru Score above 70% and vitamin C one under 60%, and most of the experts in both our guides who split on the two preferred niacinamide, largely because vitamin C is harder to keep working and harder on some skin. Vitamin C still has the stronger research for sun-damaged skin, and the two sit happily in the same routine.

Below is how the two differ, how the experts who reviewed both rated them, which they point to for dark spots, for ageing skin and for sensitive or acne-prone skin, and how to use them together.

What the gurus found
84 %
Minimalist product
Minimalist
Niacinamide 5% Serum
"I'm going to tell you go and buy the 5% not the 10%, but I would also say have a look at the rest of your skincare. If it contains niacinamide, then you don't need to do this. If it doesn't contain niacinamide and you're going for very simple moisturizers, then fine, I'm very happy if you go and buy the 5%, and this one is Dr V approved."Dr. Vanita Rattan Dr. Vanita Rattan · 4 reviewers, 84% said yes
86 %
Naturium product
Naturium
Vitamin C Complex Serum
"Naturium Vitamin C Complex Serum has been awesome, it's my favorite product in the whole Naturium line. I feel like the hyaluronic acid in it is very hydrating and plumping to the skin. It's a derivative, so it's theoretically potentially gentler, and [...] if you don't want anything with fragrance, go for Naturium's vitamin C serum with the derivative."Dr. Daniel Sugai Dr. Daniel Sugai · 11 reviewers, 86% said yes
83 %
Bubble product
Bubble
Day Dream Vitamin C + Niacinamide Tone & Texture Serum
"The Bubble Day Dream Vitamin C + Niacinamide Tone & Texture Serum is great. I've repurchased this multiple times now. It's a really nice brightening serum. It's got sodium ascorbyl phosphate, which is a vitamin C derivative that's known for brightening skin up. It's got niacinamide, alpha arbutin, which is another brightening ingredient, tranexamic acid, ceramides, and then licorice root, which is a great soothing and brightening ingredient as well as an antioxidant."No BS Beauty No BS Beauty · 8 reviewers, 83% said yes
83 %
Naturium product
Naturium
Niacinamide Gel Cream 5%
"I love this formula because it's lightweight, fast absorbing, great at keeping the skin hydrated and plump, and the ingredients are wonderful because it contains an effective 5% concentration of niacinamide along with coconut juice and plant-derived polysaccharides that help to hydrate and plump the skin. With that 5% niacinamide it's really ideal to control sebum, help to improve uneven skin texture and skin tone, so great for those with more oily and combination skin."Dr. Jenny Liu Dr. Jenny Liu · 4 reviewers, 83% said yes

What is the difference between niacinamide and vitamin C?

They are two different vitamins doing different jobs. Niacinamide is a form of vitamin B3, a water-soluble ingredient that most skin tolerates well (DermNet). It helps skin make more ceramides, the fats that hold the skin barrier together (Tanno and colleagues), slows the handover of pigment to the skin cells around it (Hakozaki and colleagues), and has been shown to reduce surface oil (Draelos and colleagues).

Vitamin C is an antioxidant. Its main job on the skin is to mop up the free radicals that UV light creates, and skin also needs it to build collagen. It slows the enzyme pigment cells use to make melanin, which is why it turns up in so many brightening serums (Telang; Al-Niaimi and Chiang). It does not absorb UV itself, so it is no substitute for sunscreen.

The practical difference is stability. Vitamin C comes in two kinds: L-ascorbic acid, the real thing with the most evidence, which light and air turn yellow as it breaks down (Telang), and derivatives, which are more stable but have much less evidence that they work like vitamin C itself (Pinnell and colleagues).

Which do the experts rate higher, niacinamide or vitamin C?

Niacinamide. It has a Guru Score above 70% from more than 10 experts, with only one saying no. Vitamin C has a Guru Score under 60% from more than 15 experts, and nearly half of them said no or had doubts.

The fair test is the eight experts in both our guides, and they lean the same way. Five rated niacinamide higher: Dr Dray, Dr. Vanita Rattan, Kelly Driscoll and Nipun Kapur said yes to niacinamide and no to vitamin C, and Cassandra Bankson, a medical esthetician, said yes to niacinamide and was mixed on vitamin C. Two went the other way, and Dr. Aleksandra Brown, a dermatologist, said yes to both.

Dr Dray, a dermatologist, calls niacinamide “one of the more evidence-based cosmetic ingredients we have available to us.” Her doubts about vitamin C are about the ingredient in the bottle: ascorbic acid, she says, is “a really fickle ingredient,” and she adds that it “kind of can turn your skin orange sometimes.” Dr. Vanita Rattan's rule for a serum that has darkened is “if it's brown, put it down.” Kelly Driscoll says simply that “Ascorbic acid specifically is something that just does not suit my skin.”

The two who rated vitamin C higher do not think niacinamide is bad. Dr. Daniel Sugai, a dermatologist who said no to dedicated niacinamide serums, says strong serums have irritated his patients' skin and that niacinamide is a helper, not the star. He puts it plainly: “it's not your main player. It's not going to replace vitamin C.” Mad About Skin, who was mixed on niacinamide, says it is “absolutely wonderful” in moderation, “but expecting it to do everything with just one ingredient, you're just setting yourself up for failure.”

Every verdict, with a link to the moment each expert gave it, is in our niacinamide guide and vitamin C guide.

Is niacinamide or vitamin C better for dark spots?

Both help, and neither is the strongest option. A 5% niacinamide moisturiser reduced hyperpigmentation compared with the plain base after 4 weeks (Hakozaki and colleagues). In a split-face melasma trial of 27 people, 44% had a good to excellent result on the 4% niacinamide side against 55% on the 4% hydroquinone side, with fewer side effects on the niacinamide side (Navarrete-Solís and colleagues).

Vitamin C looks much the same. In a 16 week split-face trial in 16 women, 5% ascorbic acid did less well than 4% hydroquinone on the women's own rating, though colour measurements found no significant difference, and side effects were far rarer on the vitamin C side (Espinal-Perez and colleagues).

Mad About Skin calls vitamin C “one of the very best ingredients for fading hyperpigmentation,” and Dr. Daniel Sugai says: “I love that vitamin C serums can lighten light freckles.” Because the two work on pigment in different ways, trials have tested them together in one product, which is where the last section comes in.

Is niacinamide or vitamin C better for wrinkles and sun damage?

Vitamin C, on the evidence. A 2023 review of seven randomised trials, with 139 people in all, found treated skin looked smoother and less wrinkled and that pigmentation lightened, though the trials were small and the authors call for more research (Correia and Magina). In a six month trial, a 5% vitamin C cream improved sun-damaged skin on the neck and arms compared with the same cream without it (Humbert and colleagues).

It also backs up sunscreen rather than replacing it. In one study, 10% topical vitamin C cut redness from UVB light by about half (Telang). Dr. Aleksandra Brown says “in the morning is a must,” and even Dr Dray, who gave vitamin C a no, says that “The formulation that has a lot of evidence behind it is ascorbic acid plus vitamin E plus ferulic acid.” In lab tests, adding ferulic acid to vitamins C and E made them more stable and doubled their protection against simulated sunlight (Lin and colleagues).

Niacinamide has a smaller case of its own. The best-known trial gave 50 women 5% niacinamide on one side of the face for 12 weeks, and that side had fewer fine lines and wrinkles, fewer dark spots and less red blotchiness (Bissett and colleagues). The niacinamide guide's own summary is that the evidence is broad but mostly small.

Which is gentler, niacinamide or vitamin C?

Niacinamide, for most skin, with one caveat. The trials mostly used 2% to 5%, and several experts think 10% and stronger serums mostly add irritation. Dr. Vanita Rattan, on the Minimalist serum below, says “go and buy the 5% not the 10%.”

Pure vitamin C is the fussier one. To get into the skin, L-ascorbic acid has to be made at a low pH, below 3.5 (Pinnell and colleagues), and that acidity is part of why it can sting. Cassandra Bankson describes it as “a form of vitamin C that is prone to degradation and can actually sting the skin.” The gentler derivatives are a sensible place to start for sensitive skin, though they have less evidence behind them.

For acne-prone skin, Nipun Kapur, a skincare consultant who is in both our guides, steers people towards niacinamide. Kapur says “Vitamin C doesn't suit those whose skin breaks out easily or those with active acne,” and suggests “a five percent niacinamide serum instead.” The research gives niacinamide some support here: a 4% nicotinamide gel did about as well as 1% clindamycin, an antibiotic gel, in an 8 week trial in 76 people (Shalita and colleagues). It is not clear-cut for vitamin C either way, since one small trial found a 5% sodium ascorbyl phosphate lotion, a vitamin C derivative, improved acne (Woolery-Lloyd and colleagues).

Can you use niacinamide and vitamin C together?

Yes. The old warning that you cannot mix them goes back to lab chemistry from the 1960s, which studied how the two interact in a solution (Guttman and Brooke). Recent trials have put niacinamide and a form of vitamin C in the same product, and the combinations were well tolerated (Barbosa and colleagues; Rocio and colleagues). In the first of those, in 50 women with melasma, a cream with 10% niacinamide and a vitamin C derivative cut melasma scores by 32% over 60 days, against 43% for 4% hydroquinone.

Dr. Sam Ellis, a dermatologist who reviewed vitamin C for our guide, says: “Vitamin C and niacinamide are completely fine together and in fact they actually work quite nicely together to combat hyperpigmentation.”

A simple way to do it is vitamin C in the morning under sunscreen, and niacinamide morning or evening. Dr. Aleksandra Brown says niacinamide “can be used both morning and evening,” and she likes it best at night. If your moisturiser or sunscreen already contains niacinamide, you may not need a separate serum at all.

Referenced products
Not medical advice. The notes here are friendly background for reading the consensus, not a substitute for advice from a board-certified dermatologist, especially with a diagnosed skin condition.