Index/ News/Ingredients
Ingredients

Azelaic acid vs niacinamide: what the experts say

The experts rate azelaic acid higher, but niacinamide's critics doubt its ceiling and the strong 10% serums. Here is which suits redness, acne and dark spots, and how the two fit together.
Save to Pinterest
The INKEY List productMinimalist productPaula's Choice product

The experts we track rate azelaic acid higher. It has a Guru Score above 90% with nobody saying no, while niacinamide sits a little over 70%. But the doubts about niacinamide are mostly about how much it can do and the strong 10% serums, not whether it works at all, and the two often share a bottle. Azelaic acid is the treatment, with the stronger evidence for rosacea and acne and prescription strengths behind it. Niacinamide is the gentle all-rounder that supports the skin barrier, calms redness and cuts oil.

Below is how the two differ, how the experts in both our guides rated them, which they point to for redness, breakouts and dark spots, and whether you can use them together.

What the gurus found
92 %
The INKEY List product
The INKEY List
Redness Relief Super Solutions 10% Azelaic Acid
"Azelaic acid is wonderful for redness, for rosacea, for sensitive prone skin. If you're acne prone, azelaic acid honestly is one of the best ingredients to really help with so many skin concerns. When I pair this up with tretinoin, [...] I do have a little bit of redness to my skin naturally and I am breakout prone, [...] and since combining azelaic acid with tretinoin, I honestly never break out like once in a while I will but not to the extent that I used to see before using this pairing."Sincerely Miss Ash Sincerely Miss Ash · 9 reviewers, 92% said yes
81 %
Paula's Choice product
Paula's Choice
10% Azelaic Acid Booster
"Paula's Choice 10% Azelaic Acid Booster helps reduce redness and inflammation while also helping brighten the skin. It's a super lightweight gel texture that layers well with other products. It does contain a little bit of salicylic acid for that mild exfoliation to help unclog pores. The key ingredients here are the azelaic acid 10% and salicylic acid 0.5% as well as licorice root extract."Dr. Aleksandra Brown Dr. Aleksandra Brown · 22 reviewers, 81% said yes
84 %
Minimalist product
Minimalist
Niacinamide 5% Serum
"I'm going to tell you go and buy the 5% not the 10%, but I would also say have a look at the rest of your skincare. If it contains niacinamide, then you don't need to do this. If it doesn't contain niacinamide and you're going for very simple moisturizers, then fine, I'm very happy if you go and buy the 5%, and this one is Dr V approved."Dr. Vanita Rattan Dr. Vanita Rattan · 4 reviewers, 84% said yes
83 %
Naturium product
Naturium
Niacinamide Gel Cream 5%
"I really recommend one I think is really ideal for everyone and I personally even for with my dry dry combination skin I love in the summer is from Naturium and a niacinamide gel cream that contains 5% niacinamide, again a great concentration of niacinamide that really does all the things we mentioned earlier helps to control sebum help with hyperpigmentation, help with uneven skin texture and skin tone but this is literally like a gel cream that absorbs really nicely helps to add some mattifying properties at the same time great to use in the morning layer under sunscreen also contains coconut juice water that is a great humectant along with Marine dry polysaccharides again a great humectant it's going to layer nicely absorbs quickly does not feel heavy great to use under sunscreen in the summer. [...] You can definitely layer this on top of your vitamin C serum so in the summertime a typical routine could be like gentle cleansing [...] and then put on this nice niacinamide 5% gel cream and you kind of really doubled up on the antioxidant the brightening benefits right there with vitamin C and niacinamide then finish off with sunscreen so that is totally doable and AOK."Dr. Jenny Liu Dr. Jenny Liu · 4 reviewers, 83% said yes

What is the difference between azelaic acid and niacinamide?

They are different kinds of ingredient that end up doing some of the same jobs. Azelaic acid is a naturally occurring acid (FDA label). It works against the bacteria involved in acne, gently slows the build-up of skin cells that clogs pores, calms inflammation and blocks an enzyme pigment cells need to make melanin (Feng and colleagues). Despite the name, it is not an AHA or BHA, and its exfoliating effect is mild.

Niacinamide is a form of vitamin B3 that most skin tolerates well (DermNet). It helps skin make ceramides, the fats that hold the barrier together (Tanno and colleagues), slows the handover of pigment to the skin cells around it (Hakozaki and colleagues), and has been shown to reduce oil on the skin's surface (Draelos and colleagues).

They also reach you differently. Azelaic acid at 15% (as a gel) and 20% (as a cream) is a prescription medicine in the US and the UK (FDA gel label, FDA cream label, UK gel label, UK cream label), while the serums sold off the shelf mostly list 10% and have far less published research behind them. Niacinamide is an everyday cosmetic ingredient, found in serums, moisturisers, cleansers and sunscreens.

Which do the experts rate higher, azelaic acid or niacinamide?

Azelaic acid. It has a Guru Score above 90% from more than a dozen experts, with nobody saying no. Niacinamide has a Guru Score a little over 70% from more than 10 experts, with one saying no and two giving mixed verdicts.

Six experts appear in both our guides, which makes for a fair side-by-side test. Three of them, Dr Dray, Hyram and Nipun Kapur, said yes to both. The other three rated azelaic acid higher, and none rated niacinamide higher.

Their reasons are about how much niacinamide can do and the strong serums, not whether it works at all. Doctorly, a channel run by two dermatologists, explains: “my knock on niacinamide is always not the lack of benefits. It's [...] the effectiveness. I believe that niacinamide has a low ceiling. I think it's a supporting ingredient at heart and will always be.” Mad About Skin says that “expecting it to do everything with just one ingredient, you're just setting yourself up for failure.” Dr. Daniel Sugai, a dermatologist, takes aim at the 10% serums: “I'd say it's way too much. It's overhyped. It's not going to work on your pores,” he says. He also says the strong serums harm some skin: “Many of my patients are getting contact dermatitis from niacinamide serums at higher doses. Definitely an irritant.”

Dr. Sugai has doubts about azelaic acid too, which is why his verdict on it is mixed. He says it is “better for soothing irritated skin and for congested pores” than for dark spots. Every verdict, with a link to the moment each expert gave it, is in our azelaic acid guide and niacinamide guide.

Is azelaic acid or niacinamide better for redness and rosacea?

Azelaic acid has the stronger case, and niacinamide is a useful support. A systematic review of five trials in 873 people found azelaic acid cut rosacea bumps and redness and did at least as well as metronidazole, another standard rosacea treatment (Liu and colleagues). It did not shrink visible blood vessels. The 15% gel is a prescription rosacea medicine in the US (FDA label).

Niacinamide's trials are smaller. A niacinamide moisturiser used twice a day for 4 weeks improved barrier function in 50 people with rosacea (Draelos and colleagues, 2005), and a 12 week trial of 5% niacinamide found less red blotchiness on the treated side of the face (Bissett and colleagues).

Dr Dray, a dermatologist, reaches for both. On azelaic acid for rosacea she says: “Azelaic acid, love it love it love it love it. It's anti-inflammatory, also great for the redness.” On niacinamide she adds: “It's great for calming down inflammation in the skin, which is a major part of rosacea, and it's really helpful for your moisture barrier.” On Doctorly, azelaic acid became the mainstay: “I shifted my core foundational ingredient to azelaic acid. This helps with rosacea including oil control and also the blemishes and redness,” one of them says.

Is azelaic acid or niacinamide better for acne and oily skin?

Azelaic acid is the acne treatment, and niacinamide is better known for oil. The 20% cream is a prescription acne medicine in the US (FDA label). Even so, a Cochrane review found azelaic acid probably works less well than benzoyl peroxide, with little or no difference between it and tretinoin (Cochrane review), so it is a solid option rather than the strongest one.

For niacinamide, an 8 week trial in 76 people found 4% nicotinamide gel did about as well as 1% clindamycin, an antibiotic gel (Shalita and colleagues). In 100 people, a 2% niacinamide product lowered the rate at which skin made oil after 2 and 4 weeks (Draelos and colleagues, 2006). That research shows less oil, not smaller pores.

Mad About Skin calls azelaic acid “a wonderful ingredient in its own right, particularly at minimizing breakouts, fading hyperpigmentation, reducing redness and inflammation.” Dr. Shereene Idriss, a dermatologist, says it helps with blackheads because “not only is it a keratolytic, meaning it breaks down keratin that's stuck together, it is also a bacterial agent that kills P. acnes.”

Is azelaic acid or niacinamide better for dark spots?

Both help, but the evidence for each is limited, and some experts see them as supporting players here. In a 24 week trial of 329 women with melasma, 20% azelaic acid cream gave good or excellent results in 65% and did about as well as 4% hydroquinone (Baliña and Graupe, 1991). That trial is decades old, and a more recent meta-analysis leaned only slightly in azelaic acid's favour over hydroquinone, with its authors calling for larger, longer studies (Albzea and colleagues).

For niacinamide, a 5% moisturiser reduced dark spots compared with the plain base after 4 weeks (Hakozaki and colleagues). In a small split-face melasma trial, 4% niacinamide did a little less well than 4% hydroquinone, with fewer side effects (Navarrete-Solís and colleagues). The trials are different, so they cannot settle which of the two fades spots better.

Dr. Sugai sees both as supporting players here. He calls it “a supporting actor, background dancer, not the main character” for dark spots, and of niacinamide he adds: “That's great for skin brightening to some degree, but it's not your main player.” Dr Dray is warmer on niacinamide, which she calls “one of the more evidence-based cosmetic ingredients we have available to us.”

Which is gentler, azelaic acid or niacinamide?

Niacinamide, for most people. It is an ingredient most skin tolerates well (DermNet). Azelaic acid commonly causes burning, stinging, tingling or itch in the first few weeks, which tends to ease as you keep going; in rosacea trials of the 15% gel, 29% had burning or tingling (FDA label). Dr Dray notes that “a lot of people find [...] that it causes them to have some itch, which is not fun either.” There have also been isolated reports of skin lightening after azelaic acid, so the US label advises people with darker skin to watch for early changes (FDA label).

Niacinamide's gentleness has a limit, though, and it is strength. Talking about a high-strength serum, Dr Dray warns: “At this [...] higher percentage, it is more likely to be irritating, and for those dealing with discoloration, anything that causes too much irritation is actually going to worsen the hyperpigmentation.” Most niacinamide trials used 2% to 5%. If your skin is sensitive, a 2% to 5% product may be the place to start, and it is worth checking how many of your products already contain niacinamide.

For azelaic acid, the UK label for the 20% cream suggests starting once a day, in the evening, for the first week, then moving to twice a day (UK label).

Can you use azelaic acid and niacinamide together?

Several experts like the pairing, though we found no trial of it. Dr Dray puts it: “Azelaic acid versus niacinamide, they tackle dark spots in different ways. So having them together, complimenting each other, is a very logical approach.” Several of the azelaic acid serums our experts review already contain niacinamide.

If you use them as separate products, Nipun Kapur, a skincare consultant, suggests an order: “If you're using The Ordinary Azelaic Acid Suspension, niacinamide comes first, suspension comes later.” Whichever way you go, it helps to add one at a time, so you can tell how your skin takes each.

Can you use azelaic acid or niacinamide while pregnant?

Azelaic acid is often suggested as one of the better-supported choices in pregnancy. The American Academy of Dermatology says it is thought to be safe to use during pregnancy, and the US gel label says very little is absorbed through the skin (FDA label). Dr. Sugai says: “It's safe during pregnancy.” The labels are still careful: the US cream label and the UK label say there are no adequate studies in pregnant women (FDA label, UK label).

We found little published research on using niacinamide on the skin during pregnancy or while breastfeeding. Nipun Kapur, a skincare consultant, includes a niacinamide serum in a routine for pregnant and nursing mothers and calls it safe. Anyone who is pregnant or trying to be may want to talk to their doctor or midwife before starting either one.

Referenced products
Not medical advice. The notes here are friendly background for reading the consensus, not a substitute for advice from a board-certified dermatologist, especially with a diagnosed skin condition.