Where they part company
Alexandra Anele calls Tatcha Indigo Overnight Repair Serum in Cream mixed. Doctorly calls it yay. Two experts, one product, takes about 3 weeks apart, and opposite conclusions. Their own words are above; we are not going to tell you which of them is right.
What the whole panel says
These two are not the only voices on Tatcha Indigo Overnight Repair Serum in Cream. Across every independent expert take we hold, it carries a Guru Score of 83% from 10 experts, which is the share of them who approved it. The other 8 experts we hold takes from are counted in it too. See every take on it →
Why we only pair takes from the same month
A formula gets reworked, a price moves, and a product people loved in one year is not the product they are handed in the next. Two takes far apart in time can look like a disagreement when they are really a description of a product that changed. So a face-off only pairs experts whose videos went up within a month of each other, and neither take here is sponsored.